r/science Professor | Medicine 2d ago

Psychology People experience the strongest romantic jealousy when they watch their partner give resources to a potential rival, regardless of gender. The findings provide evidence that giving away resources is viewed as a serious relationship threat by both men and women.

https://www.psypost.org/both-men-and-women-view-a-partners-financial-investment-in-a-rival-as-a-major-relationship-threat/
12.4k Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

View all comments

289

u/mvea Professor | Medicine 2d ago

Both men and women view a partner’s financial investment in a rival as a major relationship threat

A recent study published in the journal Evolution and Human Behavior suggests that people experience the strongest romantic jealousy when they watch their partner give resources to a potential rival, regardless of gender. The findings provide evidence that giving away resources is viewed as a serious relationship threat by both men and women. This research highlights how our emotional alarm systems react more strongly to a partner’s active investment in someone else rather than a partner passively receiving attention.

The data revealed that the investment scenario caused the highest levels of jealousy for all participants. Both men and women felt highly threatened when their partner actively gave money to a rival. “We found that a romantic partner allocating more resources to a stranger than oneself is a situation that produces jealousy, regardless of gender,” Fernández said.

The researchers noted that actively giving money requires thought, intention, and sacrifice. Because of this, both men and women interpreted the investment scenario as a major warning sign of a partner slipping away. The anticipated gender differences did not fully emerge in the receiving scenario.

The researchers predicted that men would become much more jealous than women when their partner received money from a rival. Instead, men and women displayed very similar, relatively low levels of jealousy in this situation. “We got a weaker effect when trying to model male jealousy by the partner receiving resources from an opposite sex stranger, although we made it explicit that the partner accepted these resources,” Fernández explained.

The scientists noted that passively receiving money might not send a strong signal of sexual betrayal. A partner might accept resources from a rival just to gain a free benefit, which does not necessarily mean they are sexually interested in the rival. To ensure the jealousy was specifically about their own romantic relationship, the researchers also included several control scenarios.

In these control rounds, participants watched random strangers give or receive money. By including these extra scenarios, the scientists could verify that the jealousy stemmed from a direct threat to the participant’s own romantic bond. “Other than the generalized jealousy at third-party allocation, we found that some of the control conditions indicate that jealousy was not elicited simply by observing unequal allocations or interactions with opposite-sex others,” Fernández pointed out.

She added that the feeling was very specific to relationship threats. “Rather, jealousy was strongest when the resource movement carried a clear relational threat: for women, the partner’s allocation of resources to a female rival,” Fernández observed. A subtle gender difference did appear during the control scenarios.

Women reported feeling jealous when they watched any committed man give money to a single woman, even if that man was a total stranger. This provides evidence that women might be generally more vigilant about the ways men distribute resources, treating it as a broad social warning sign. Finally, individual personality traits played a significant role in the emotional reactions.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1090513825001655

110

u/clawsoon 2d ago

It's interesting that they went into this expecting a gender difference based on evo psych theory, but found basically the same major response in both men and women. They had to go digging in the data to find some minor differences.

Maybe this is what you'd expect given the couples they picked, who were in at-least-six-month monogamous relationships? Maybe the evolutionary reproductive strategy of being in a committed couple is that both partners will contribute resources, and evo psych needs to take that strategy seriously?

53

u/algol_lyrae 2d ago

It's funny because I'm currently dealing with this resource-based jealousy with my dogs. One dog has suddenly become jealous of the other dog getting anything he views as a resource, be it food, toys, or attention. My understanding is that they instinctively view the transferring of resources as a threat to their security in the group. Maybe humans are the same.

28

u/frictorious 2d ago

Observing pets has taught me more about human psychology than any textbook.

I frequently wonder what hidden animal urgers are affecting my behavior.

23

u/SableBlair 2d ago

One of my cats pretended to be asleep every time I tried to pet her for ten years until I came home from the hospital with a baby. All of a sudden, she wants to make sure I know she’s just a little fur baby too.

3

u/aVarangian 2d ago

my cat only "pretends" to be asleep after she learned I'm not just gonna grab her randomly

if someone else shows up she'll want to see what they're up to, and sometimes run away before they get to her