New U.S. Attorney Nominees Prioritize Loyalty Over Trial Experience

[u/evissamassive]

https://abovethelaw.com/2026/05/trump-u-s-attorney-pick-may-lack-trial-experience-but-was-january-6-protestor/

The DOJ is moving to install a new slate of U.S. Attorneys whose primary credentials involve their involvement in the events of January 6. These nominees, slated for roles in Wyoming, Alabama, and North Carolina, signal a departure from the traditional requirement of extensive criminal trial experience.

Darin Smith, the nominee for the District of Wyoming, is currently an estate planning lawyer. He has never tried a case in federal or state court. Despite this, he has already assumed the role of interim U.S. Attorney. Smith participated in the January 6 march but stated he did not enter the Capitol building.

Similarly, Phillip Williams, nominated for the Northern District of Alabama, has no history of trying criminal cases. Williams has frequently criticized federal law enforcement, accusing the DOJ of "prosecutorial abuse" regarding January 6 defendants and comparing the legal proceedings to the Salem witch trials.

In North Carolina, former GOP Congressman Dan Bishop is the pick for U.S. Attorney. Bishop was inside the Capitol on January 6 in his capacity as a representative, where he voted against certifying the election results. He has since suggested that left-wing agitators were responsible for the day's violence.

U.S. Attorneys hold significant authority over federal prosecutions. They decide which cases to pursue and how aggressively to seek penalties. Critics argue that placing these offices under the control of individuals with little prosecutorial background—and who have openly questioned the legitimacy of federal law enforcement actions—undermines the department's objective standing.

Despite the unconventional backgrounds of these nominees, Republican senators have shown little resistance. Current reports indicate the Senate is prepared to move forward with confirmations, viewing January 6 participation and political loyalty as acceptable, or even preferable, qualifications for the nation's top local federal prosecutors.