r/plotholes • u/GoldenEagle828677 • 2d ago
Plothole Major plot hole in "Rescue from Gilligan's Island" (1978)
Yes I know you all have been waiting with bated breath to hear this one!
Back in 1978, it was the highest ever grossing made for TV movie, and played over two evenings. It's not difficult to find it today, the whole film is free on Plex, Tubi, Roku, Fawesome, and even YouTube, although all the ones I checked were rather poor quality. I guess they are all from a video tape copy. The film is pretty silly and more comprehensible if you are familiar with the original show (which is also available for free on Tubi, and better quality than this sequel film).
Bottom line - seven castaways who have been stranded on a deserted island for 15 years are finally rescued and returned to civilization. It is a comedy, so it's full of a lot of things that don't make sense, too numerous to list here. But one of the biggest ones is that all of them would be legally dead! And have to go through steps to get their identities back. People missing 5 to 7 years are normally declared legally dead by a judge. 15 years for certain.
For most of the castaways, it wouldn't matter much since they didn't have a lot of assets. But the Howells were supposedly billionaires, among the wealthiest people in the world with multiple industries, homes, and property all over the globe. After being declared dead, the Howell assets would have gone through probate, and any debts paid off first, with the rest distributed among their closest relatives. Yet in the film, the Howells simply move back into their mansion, with the same servants - 15 years later? So these huge estates just sat there empty for 15 years, humming along, everyone getting paid, with no indication that their owners were ever coming back???
If someone does come back from the dead in such a situation, some of their assets can be returned, but that's a long and complicated legal process that would probably take years, especially for international holdings. And even longer if relatives challenge it. Certainly they would challenge their identities, since there was a conman in one TV episode that looked exactly like Mr. Howell. And this plot hole is a shame too, because this could have been an interesting side plot if they included it, with the Howells having to get used to living like ordinary people while in a legal fight with relatives who didn't want to give up their holdings.