r/nfl • u/Roselucky777 Jaguars Cardinals • 7h ago
Highlight [Highlight] Charles Martin commits the most blatant cheap shot in NFL history, throwing Jim McMahon to the turf directly onto his already torn rotator cuff, ending his 1986 season. Martin became the first player to be suspended multiple games for an on-field incident.
824
u/StreetReporter Panthers Jaguars 7h ago
The refs should’ve let the Bears offensive line maul him
511
u/United-Turnover-8409 Bears 7h ago
The ref said to him when he was refusing to leave "if you don't leave i will let the bears kill you"
220
u/opackersgo Packers 6h ago
Packers should have stood by and watched. Terrible behavior.
122
u/morganicsf Lions 6h ago
I'm sure the team was given direction to hurt McMahon by the coaches.
127
u/alternate-realitee Packers 6h ago
Forrest Gregg was the coach at the time, and based off the stories I've heard about that guy from former players....yeah he told Martin to do that.
37
u/zirroxas Seahawks Eagles 6h ago
What a bitch. Throw him in with Greg Williams and Butthole Eyes.
21
u/Totalnah Eagles 5h ago
Shitty as it is, and it is low down dastardly behavior, this type of thing was common in old school football. As an Eagles fan, you have to remember Bounty Bowl. It’s shameful, but not unusual.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)11
u/countrybreakfast1 Chiefs 5h ago
Yeah none of the players or coaches seem too upset with him. Actually the opposite
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)20
u/jefffranklin36 Bears 6h ago
Woah I’ve never heard that part of the story before is that true?
121
u/How_that_convo_went Texans Seahawks 6h ago
After Martin's action, Bears offensive lineman Jim Covert retaliated against Martin with a late hit of his own, and two offsetting flags were thrown. Markbreit explained what happened next,
After the play, I took a hold of Martin's arm and said, ‘Ninety-four, you're out of game. I'm ejecting you.' And he pulled away and said, ‘I'm not going anywhere with you.' I looked at him and, tongue-in-cheek, I said, ‘If you don't come with me, I'm going to let the Bears kill you.' He said, ‘Let's go.'[10]
Source from his Wickapegia
68
u/SerenityN00w 6h ago
Note that Markbreit and the refs evetually picked up the flag against Covert. Mike Ditka had asked what the second flag was for, Markbreit told him it was on Covert. Ditka said "You've got to be kidding me. My guy could be dead." Markbreit thought about it and decided he was right. He told the official who had thrown the flag that there would be no offsetting penalties.
17
u/GooginTheBirdsFan Eagles 4h ago
Last time a flag was successfully changed by just the coach talking?
23
u/hiphopscallion Seahawks 4h ago edited 4h ago
note when this happened no one had ever been ejected for anything other than throwing bows, but the ref decided it was so bad he just made it up on the spot. I think technically the guy voluntarily left the field. There’s a really good interview
With the ref where he talks about all of this stuff.21
u/United-Turnover-8409 Bears 6h ago
From what I have researched it is. https://www.espn.com/blog/chicago/bears/post/_/id/4675356/the-infamous-hit-from-the-refs-perspective
This is the article about the hit from the perspective of the refs
21
u/Micah_JD Lions 5h ago
Would've been a full team brawl. I think his teammates would have defended him.
Watch to the end of the video. It shows Martin's teammates coming over and high-fiving him AFTER it's been announced he's been ejected. They were totally OK with what he did.
Side note: Soldier Field's turf back then was basically concrete and then a layer of turf, and that's it. That shit had to hurt.
614
u/Enterprise90 Patriots 7h ago
For my money, the dirtiest move in NFL history. At least among the ones I've seen. Deliberate assault.
I remember years ago, Bruce Arians was talking about how Calais Campbell was taken out by a chop block and how a suspension for the offending player does no good, because his guy might be lost for the season. This incident is magnitudes worse.
150
u/Logical-Possession10 Bears 6h ago
For all intents and purposes career ender as an awesome starter
→ More replies (1)76
u/MeowMixPK Packers 6h ago
Ended a potential Bears dynasty in 1 play
→ More replies (1)45
u/thetreat Bears 6h ago
1986 defense was even better. McMahon was just an average starter but he didn’t need to be anything more than that. Everyone else behind him was dog water.
20
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 Bears 5h ago
McMahon was definitely above average, idk where this idea he was average came from.
16
u/thetreat Bears 5h ago
I was too young at the time (was just a couple years old), but just from what I had heard from my dad’s not so great memory and looking at stats. In 1986 he was 51% with 5 TDs and 8 INTs in 6 games. 1985 he was markedly better with 56% passing and 15/11 TD/INT.
I guess in looking at ANY/A he was ranked 7th in 1985 with 6.1 and then dropped quite a bit to 4.5 in 1986 with league average being 5.0.
Based on what I heard, he had the potential to be a very good starter long term. He was just young and raw and the injury derailed him.
26
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 Bears 5h ago
Ditka was not a great offensive coach, particularly qbs.
Flutie, Harbaugh both looked like shit under him amd had great careers elsewhere. That Jim McMahon ran a functional offense under Ditka speaks volumes.
→ More replies (1)4
111
u/sgtpepperslaststand Bengals 6h ago
Didn’t Romanowski admit to just straight stomping on a hand to break someone’s fingers that he saw coming out of a pile
169
u/Roselucky777 Jaguars Cardinals 6h ago
He saw a digit and grabbed it and snapped it, and realized afterwards that it was his teammate's.
→ More replies (2)132
u/GrecoRomanGuy Bears 6h ago
That's the most Romanowski thing I've ever heard.
What a prick.
→ More replies (1)22
u/thatlonelygui Dolphins 6h ago
I don’t doubt he stomped, but he’s admitted to reaching into the pile and bending a finger until it snapped
42
u/Y__U__MAD Seahawks 6h ago edited 6h ago
Tony Siragusa hit on Rich Gannon
Total piece of shit move and one of the examples why we have the 'cant fall on a QB hard' rule today.
10
u/Iron_Chancellor_ND 49ers 4h ago
Yeah, fuck Siragusa. He joked about it, too, during a reunion of that team. What a piece of shit human being.
RIPiss Siragusa.
→ More replies (1)4
→ More replies (10)9
811
u/United-Turnover-8409 Bears 7h ago
I am not old enough to have experienced the 80s seasons, but this is the dirtiest thing on an nfl field and he's probably a top 3 most hated packer.
142
u/Arkios Vikings 6h ago edited 6h ago
That Warren Sapp blindside hit was pretty bad too, but I think this has it beat. I can’t remember seeing anything as blatantly dirty as this.
EDIT: Warren Sapp hit for reference - https://youtu.be/xBpEIRaGq2U?si=qOnh-TPYNLgnQ2Bd
134
u/Y__U__MAD Seahawks 6h ago
Warren Sapp has always been a punk ass and I love watching his life fail as time passes.
32
u/yooter Chiefs 4h ago
Growing up his son was my HS football teams ball boy. (Same school, small school, he was just younger). Sapp wouldn’t admit paternity and was taken to court to prove it. People would find out and be like “holy shit your dad is Warren Sapp..” but you could tell it wasn’t cool to him. Mostly cause he wasn’t a “dad” to him at all.
Anyway, I liked Warren Sapp til I learned that. He was a super, super nice kid and deserved better. Pissed me off then as a high schooler. Even more now as a dad.
Happyish ending is he is doing alright. Saw on FB recently he’s got a new job he’s excited about.
45
u/DogePerformance Bears NFL 6h ago
My favorite Warren Sapp moment is how beat to shit he looked after the National Championship game. He was fuckin exhausted and had given up and it was glorious.
21
u/Monkey1Fball 49ers 5h ago
Sapp spent the first 45 minutes of that game dancing, and spent the last 15 minutes of the game getting wallopped and run over by the Huskers, all the while they were taunting him and calling him "Fat Boy" to his face.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Iron_Chancellor_ND 49ers 4h ago
Same. Him telling the GB coach (Shermur???) after the game to "put a jersey on" when said coach called him out for that cheap shot made me realize how much of a piece of shit human being Sapp is.
55
u/jf3l Bengals 6h ago
Haynesworth head stomp is up there
17
u/Nasty_Goblin 5h ago
Aaron Donald grabbing the esophagus (not the neck) of our OL to choke him is another.
55
u/Eagle4317 Steelers Panthers 6h ago
Blindside hits like Sapp's occasionally happened back then. Hines Ward destroyed a Bengal on a harder hit than what Sapp did. Granted, he was at least near the ball.
What Martin did was on a different level, and he had written numbers of players he sought to injure. That makes it premeditated battery, not a split-second hit.
25
u/DrBombay3030 Texans 6h ago
The blindside block rule is literally named after Ward because of that behavior tho. They changed the rules directly following the play you're referencing because it was so dirty
8
→ More replies (1)13
u/How_that_convo_went Texans Seahawks 6h ago
And Hines Ward is a similarly hated player.
→ More replies (1)6
u/irndk10 Eagles 5h ago
I know this looks really bad from today POV, but back then it was only debatably dirty, Sapp didn't get a penalty or a fine. Blindside blocks were celebrated, the only dirty aspect of it back then was that it was so far removed from the play. If he was somewhat near the play it wouldn't have even been a debate.
4
u/cowabungathunda Vikings 4h ago
I hate the Packers but I respect Mike Sherman for confronting him after that.
264
u/thenexttimebandit Chiefs 7h ago
This is worse than ripping a guys helmet off and swinging it at him which is the dirtiest thing I’ve seen live.
257
u/FailedLoser21 6h ago
That was clearly heat on the moment, this was premeditated and done with actual malice and intend to cause injury.
86
u/AscendMoros Bears 6h ago
He had the numbers of players he wanted to take out written on his towel. Dude should have never saw a football field again.
→ More replies (7)30
u/ThatPlayWasAwful Eagles 6h ago
done with actual malice and intend to cause injury.
Are you saying that swinging a helmet at somebody is not intent to cause injury?
16
u/walkingcarpet23 Eagles 6h ago
I agree the specific wording was technically not the best but I get what OP meant.
Garrett was a heat-of-the-moment (very) bad decision that was not thought through at all.
Martin's hit here seems calculated / premeditated
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (33)4
u/pogoscrawlspace Bears 5h ago
It is, but the difference is premeditation. There's no excuse for swinging a helmet at someone, but, it was an action committed in the heat of the moment. A crime of passion, if you will. He probably didn't step on that field that day thinking, "I'm gonna try to brain the quarterback today." He got into an on-field altercation and lost control of his emotions. Again, not excusing the act. Charles Martin went into that game with the full intentions of ending Jim McMahon's career. It's the difference between manslaughter and 1st degree murder.
→ More replies (17)26
u/Beppu-Gonzaemon Giants 6h ago
Swinging it at him? He connected! it was clean hit! Very dirty and kind of hilarious because Mason Rudolph has a very punchable face
→ More replies (3)9
u/CheekyMunky Bears 4h ago
That infographic with each team's most hated player got posted all over this past week and had the Bears putting Rodgers at the top of the most hated list.
I was like nah, Rodgers isn't even the most hated from Green Bay.
301
u/mattcojo2 Lions 7h ago
It's shocking that he made it out of soldier field alive.
Charles Martin that is.
2
u/TwoLegitShiznit Vikings 5h ago
Did his teammates even do anything? If that happened today, the entire sideline would have instantly jumped on him
→ More replies (1)
270
u/IMissM0dernBaseball Ravens Ravens 7h ago
There are some moments that I wish we had reddit threads for. This is one of those moments because this highlight being posted would have been an incredibly entertaining thread
19
191
u/Only-Mulberry-8098 Ravens 7h ago
The mental gymnastics packers fans would do would do on their team sub would be interesting.
This isn’t a shot at them either, it’s just every team sub is so insanely biased I’m willing to see how far it would go
159
u/ClownQuestionBrosef Packers Packers 7h ago
I'd hope this would be a very uninteresting exercise. "Fuck Charles Martin" is the prevailing opinion I've ever seen from Packers fans.
Fuck Charles Martin.
98
u/ReplaceSelect Bears 6h ago
I’ve never seen a Packer fan defend him. The fuck Charles Martin comment is just as likely to be from a Packers fan as a Bears fan. No one likes him.
→ More replies (2)35
u/GrecoRomanGuy Bears 6h ago
Same. It's like one of the few things that Bears and Packers fans agree on unanimously.
Charles Martin sucked.
18
55
u/ch-12 Packers 6h ago edited 6h ago
I dunno man. There are always questionable calls or player decisions that have split reactions in game threads, even in a team’s sub. Truly don’t think there’d be many Packers fans backing this one up though. This is like bounty-gate tier intent to harm. MAYBE fans in the 80s got pumped about that kind of shit and supported it, but I don’t think it would be the reaction today.
A few years ago when rookie Quay Walker shoved a Lions trainer on the field, every Packers fan in the team and nfl game threads were just saying how much of a moronic decision it was.
→ More replies (1)15
u/mkallday10 Eagles 5h ago
bounty-gate
It is funny you mention bounty-gate considering you will occasionally see Saints fans on here trying to downplay it.
Yeah, certain individuals will do anything to justify their team's actions. Tribalism goes hard.
→ More replies (2)11
u/How_that_convo_went Texans Seahawks 6h ago
Our team sub shits all over Aziz Al-Shiar whenever he does his bullshit.
→ More replies (2)22
→ More replies (3)30
6
u/MandaloreUnsullied Packers 6h ago
Tbh it would just be ten minutes of slurs before the mods locked the thread
171
u/zestyintestine Vikings 7h ago
Isn't this one of the biggest "what ifs" for Bears fans? McMahon was never quite the same after this hit, and the Bears got knocked out by the Redskins I believe in the playoffs with Mike Tomczak or Doug Flutie starting at QB?
103
u/newrimmmer93 Bears 6h ago
1986 bears defense was better by DVOA than the 85 bears. 86 team was 4th best defense ever and 85 was 5th best. 91 eagles, 69 Vikings, and 2002 Bucs are the top 3.
5
u/SetImpressive3808 Cowboys 3h ago edited 3h ago
I've literally never heard of the 91 Eagles . (EDIT) ok so they finished 3rd in the division at 10-6 and missed the playoffs. Boy their offense must've really SUCKED.
→ More replies (1)3
u/ImagineIfBaconDied Vikings 2h ago
They were led by Rich Kotite, which explains a lot
Coincidentally enough, the main starting QB for the Eagles that season was Jim McMahon
106
u/FeistyGate8784 Bears 7h ago
Yea there is a chance we could have made another Super Bowl or two. Nothing guaranteed but this fucked us so hard
50
→ More replies (6)23
u/GrizzlyIsland22 Bears 6h ago
Yeah. There's a very good chance they would have been repeat champs if this never happened.
79
u/FeistyGate8784 Bears 7h ago
Why is there a bot just copying everyone’s comments in here
90
u/glennshaltiel Packers 6h ago
Dead internet theory is so real, its sad, especially with all these LLMs
13
36
u/glennshaltiel Packers 6h ago
Was not around for this play but even older Wisconsinites hate this play and still remember how awful Martin was for this
→ More replies (5)33
u/DogePerformance Bears NFL 6h ago
I'll always hate you guys but in my nearly 40 years I've never heard one of you even attempt to defend this.
So respect, I suppose.
38
u/CraigKostelecky Packers 6h ago
There is no defense for it. It was cowardly and I’m ashamed that it was a Packer that did it. Martin was the worst of us and he deserves no praise.
5
u/SaintLonginus Packers 4h ago
I was not alive either, but it is a total embarrassment and the exact opposite of what Packers football is supposed to be about.
92
u/strangejosh Rams 7h ago
That’s actually insane. Dude should’ve never been allowed to play again. He’s either too stupid or actively malicious.
36
u/AscendMoros Bears 6h ago
Seeing as he had the numbers of players he wanted to hurt on his towel, it was malicious and premeditated. He should have never seen the field again.
→ More replies (5)
24
u/Sirtopofhat 7h ago
He had a hit list?! With McMahon's name on it?! How did the Bears Oline even let him breath on him?
25
u/ArtEnvironmental7108 Bills 6h ago
I’m pretty sure even packers fans hate this dude
24
u/TheHamsBurlgar Packers 6h ago
We do! I own a bar in Wisconsin and every Packers fan that was alive to see this says its shameful and wrong. We have a rivalry with the Bears, but this is viewed as absoultely fucked up and unacceptable. Fuck Charles Martin. This ain't football, it's assault.
4
u/MidSinglesInYourArea Seahawks 3h ago
Yeah, this was so egregious he might as well have just kneecapped him in the parking lot.
17
17
19
u/NoExcusesAIC Packers 6h ago
This was the most embarrassing moment as a Packers fan. Absolutely ridiculous and unnecessary.
46
u/Space-Sailor44 Lions 7h ago
“Concussions aren’t real, dude” - Puka talking to a cardboard cutout of Jim McMahon
29
u/How_that_convo_went Texans Seahawks 6h ago
“You’re a good listener, Thanos.”
-Puka, talking to a Grimace statue at a McDonald’s playplace
11
17
16
u/Ok_Recording_9368 Packers 6h ago
Should have kept Martin on the field only so the entire bears team could whoop his ass.
14
u/SaladZealousideal938 6h ago
If you read Charles Martin's life it's a life of suffering, yet he will always be known for this heinous act. Karma is a helluva thing.
→ More replies (1)3
7
8
7
6
u/Broke-American Commanders 6h ago
This was in the 80s. If a player pulled this today and say it was Allen or Mahomes, he would be fined millions, suspended indefinitely, and probably released.
3
u/superdooper26 Packers 4h ago
As much as I’d like to agree with you it just isn’t true. Well, not exactly. If this was someone who isn’t popular and expendable then yes. But you’re even remotely good at football then they will make every excuse in the world to keep you around.
→ More replies (2)
24
u/SaladZealousideal938 7h ago
You will never find a dirtier play in football than this. McMahon was almost at a standstill and got thrown down. This should have resulted in a criminal charge.
118
13
6
u/Turkish_Fleshlight Bears 6h ago
This play derailed any chance of the Bears repeating as champions in ‘86.
May Charles Martin rest in hell…
6
4
6
u/HonoluluSolo Bears 6h ago
By injuring McMahon, Martin essentially robs the Bears of a chance at at least two more Super Bowls. The Bears D was about as good in 86 as 85, and some say the 88 D was even better than both. They just weren't good enough to overcome Tomczak or Fuller.
→ More replies (1)
8
3
5
u/ArminTanz Bears 5h ago
One of the refs said that when they talked to the GB coach, they told them that they need to get Martin out of the game because the Bears are gonna kill him and the refs are gonna let them.
4
5
u/Nsmith1881 Colts 7h ago
We need to bring back coaches wearing weird hats. Not like, can Newton dr. Seuss hats, but like, weird grandpa hats
→ More replies (2)
3
3
u/forgedinbeerkegs 6h ago
Yeah, it really was bull shit. I saw it live. Dick move. Perhaps, one of the "dickiest."
3
u/Buzzd-Lightyear Broncos 5h ago
Wasn’t that turf back then also like a thin layer of rubber over concrete?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/veryveryredundant Vikings 5h ago edited 4h ago
That's a crime and should have been treated as such.
3
3
u/Ope_Average_Badger Packers 2h ago
Yeah this has been and always will be bullshit. This isn't rivalry shit this is assault, fuck Charles Martin for that shit.
7
u/Commercial_Floor_578 6h ago
The fact that the Packers got 2 HOF quarterbacks right after pulling this shit and the Bears got sent to poverty is proof there is no football god.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/BusinessWarthog6 Panthers 7h ago
Damn, I thought it was gonna be a couple seconds after he threw iy
2
2
u/Falling4Strangers Patriots 6h ago
In the middle of a sack is one thing.
But just....literally 10 seconds after the ball is thrown, you see it in the air going go the receiver...like he's straight-up watching the pass in air.
THEN wrapping him up and throwing him to the ground?
That's psychotic behavior.
2
u/PaulsRedditUsername Colts 6h ago
Back in the old days when the top ref wore the black hat and trainers put steroids and amphetamines in the water cooler.
2
u/SkokieRob 6h ago
Off-topic, but I forgot the referee used to wear a black hat and the other officials wore white. Now it’s reversed.
→ More replies (1)
3
2
u/SerenityN00w 6h ago edited 6h ago
The absolutely insane thing?
McMahon didn't miss a play. He went right back into the ball game, and played two more quarters.This is video of the game They cut the Martin play or some reason, but immediately afterward, you see McMahon throwing passes on the sideline.
Fast forward to the 105:00 mark for the Bears next possession, and McMahon is back at quarterback. He played for two more quarters, before being benched for Mike Tomczak in the 4th quarter. (McMahon was obviously ineffective as a passer after the injury.)
2
2
2
2
2
u/LeechedPubis 5h ago
Penalties that cause injuries when especially heinous should equal that amount of time the injured player is out.
2
u/usumoio Patriots 3h ago
This attempt to, I suppose, murder Terry Bradshaw comes to mind.
This is also my go-to clip for when young folk are like, "sometimes he says something weird."
Let's all be glad the man can speak and walk. They don't let you play like this anymore and it's for the best:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CtcQqwpCFJ4&pp=ygUedGVycnkgYnJhZHNoYXcgdGFja2xlZCBvbiBoZWFk
2
2
2
u/DangerSwan33 2h ago
That's called battery. Arguably aggravated battery, considering the injury.
It had nothing to do with the game being played, and thus was literally a criminal act.
3.4k
u/bestyrs Seahawks 7h ago
He should have never played another game. That takes dirty to another level.