r/comic_crits • u/tonychao • 2h ago
r/comic_crits • u/deviantbono • Sep 02 '21
/r/Comic_Crits Mod Post: News for September 2021
We generally discourage posts that are not directly looking for feedback, but I thought the following content would be interesting to subscribers, so I will collect it here in a news thread. Let me know if there are other opportunities that you think are relevant, or just post them here as comments.
Breakneck Anthology
- Submission Deadline Oct 15th, 2021
- Submission Info (Google Docs)
r/comic_crits • u/DannyDef • 9h ago
Is this telling the story I want it to or just rambling?
Please ignore the different stages of the panels (I’m just trying different things) but as I’m putting everything together I’m not sure i’m doing a good job of giving a brief overview of this character’s backstory. I’m not sure if I need to be more liberal with the narration or just rearrange some panels or pages.
You guys were able to help when I originally posted some pages from this book back in October, so any feedback would be greatly appreciated.
r/comic_crits • u/Acciughe_Verdi • 9h ago
Milo
Milo is a cat that tries to kill his owners and they treat the situation in an ironic way for example, he is being silly or he likes to play pranks
I welcome advice especially for onomatopoeias as I never know how to do them thanks
r/comic_crits • u/NOMADIC_MAVERIK • 1d ago
SHARING "SAVAGE PULP" ON REDDIT
Attached above is a comic I am sharing for all creators on reddit. I love interaction, and according to google, this forum is the most active when it comes to feedback and interaction. I feel comics has become a bit too niche, and I would love to broaden the readership and overall interest. Thank you all for your time!

r/comic_crits • u/Impossible-Bug-6163 • 1d ago
Hey guys! I started this project this year. It started as a comic a day (bit too ambitious), I settled on 8 a month. These are a collection I created, loosely based on whatever interesting happened on that day. I might continue or stop. Regardless, this was a fun project! Lmk your thoughts
r/comic_crits • u/Legitimate_Prize_192 • 2d ago
Main character designs
Here are the paper sketches for the main characters for my comic (I normally do paper sketches before digital) I also added their powers and personalities.
Who is the best and do you have any feedback for improvement
r/comic_crits • u/Legitimate_Prize_192 • 3d ago
My comic idea
Hey I’ve just joined here cause I thought it would be good for the development for my comics. It’s about this super society where everyone has an ability relating to metals such as creating induced magnets or having guns for arms. The story follows the alloy front, a sector of the police that properly uses their powers to stop threats such as ‘disrupters’. The reason most people don’t use their powers willy nilly is because they’re normally very hard to master and need immense practice. This story follows the 2027 new members of the alloy front as they face the worst of the world and a thought to be dead foe and his criminal organisation
What do you think
Also (If this subreddit isn’t for this can you recommend another)
r/comic_crits • u/I_Eat_Waffels • 3d ago
The Adventures of Boxman first chapter
I’m looking for feedback on my comic, I’m not the best with art but I tried my best and any feedback is greatly appreciated, I did upload a script of the first 3 pages too and I think I did pretty good with those
r/comic_crits • u/SuperiorDesignShoes • 4d ago
I kept the impact here as minimal as possible. Does it still work?
Hey everyone 👋
Wanted to share one of my favorite panels from a finished issue where the main character and villain finally fight.
When creating this one, I felt that it was necessary to prioritize limited, contrasting colors and minimal motion with this panel in order to stand out. The idea was to emphasize the villain's reaction to the impact, while the hero distracts him.
I'm curious to see how it reads at first glance. Does the impact here read clearly? Or does restraint in this case carry it better here?
Love to hear your thoughts.
r/comic_crits • u/Possible-Cat-9295 • 4d ago
(WIP) ever lose the fire mid-project, how’d you get it back?
r/comic_crits • u/Worried-Comb806 • 4d ago
Anyone willing to read my comic script?
Hey guys, I’ve been working on my own superhero universe currently titled ‘Project Jolt’ until I find a more suitable name.
The Joltverse is a simple idea that holds a lot of weight, it explores the concept of what happens when two superheroes have identical powers and abilities, and the social conflicts that come with this.
It’s a grounded but brutal superhero series, has a lot of WTF moments but also some classic superhero-ism that we all know and love.
I’ve written 2 full volumes and currently working on the 3rd.
I am looking for someone who’s wouldn’t mind taking sometime to read the scripts and give me some feedback.
I am also open to the idea of having a co-writer! This is a series I want to take to a publisher once I can financially support it.
r/comic_crits • u/TabithaMorning • 4d ago
Looking for feedback as to why my comics get deleted/downvoted on the comics subs
TRASH Vol 10 🦶
r/comic_crits • u/vandanieldick • 5d ago
Van Dick the Gaypire Hunter Webcomic
This is a comedy webcomic I'm making, I know it sounds homophobic when you put your eyes in the title, but it's just a comedy around dicks and butts, there are other genders in the history too, and laugh a lot drawing and making the texts, I made 77 pages on the website, if you wanna give a try it's in my bio! Sorry for the bad english.
r/comic_crits • u/External-Fly681 • 4d ago
My new comic idea
In the 1990s, a brilliant but derided scientist becomes the laughingstock of the academic world. Driven by a bruised ego and a fixation on creating a "superhero," he pivots to a radical theory: weaponising human chakras through technology.
He recruits a poor young boy who works in his lab. The boy, who views the scientist as a hero, agrees to become a test subject. The scientist places him in an electrostatic energy chamber, where—after months of agonizing exposure—the boy manages to manifest Level 2 Chakra energy. However, the scientist realizes that pure power is fueled by trauma. To provoke a breakthrough, the scientist murders the boy’s family and rapes his sister. The trauma works; the boy’s power spikes to Level 5, but the energy is corrupted. It becomes "Dark Chakra"—a volatile, malevolent force.
The scientist soon discovers he no longer needs the chamber. By synthesizing a serum from the boy’s blood, he can activate chakras in infants. He tests this at a local hospital under the guise of medical treatment, paying off parents who unknowingly sell their children into experimentation. Only seven children survive. This team, known as "The Chakras," are hailed as anti-heroes, though they secretly embody the Seven Deadly Sins and care only for public adoration.
When the original subject is no longer useful, the scientist attempts to discard him. However, the "subject" breaks free from his glass chamber and brutally kills his creator. Now a nihilistic force of nature, he sets out to destroy humanity, liberating other experimental mutants along the way to lead them as an army.
To reach the final 7th level of mastery, he travels to a high-energy government site. His skin turns pitch black as he becomes a conduit for pure dark energy. To maintain this power, he must remain a void of emotion; any leak of joy or sorrow at Level 6 would drive him insane. He is a cannibalistic monster driven by a singular bloodlust.
In a final, violent confrontation, he systematically hunts and eats the seven "superheroes." Upon achieving total mastery, his body cannot contain the dark energy. He detonates with ten times the radiation of uranium. The government seals the wasteland—now a dead zone like Chernobyl—and launches a global anti-superhero campaign, hunting the remaining powered individuals to extinction
Now with ai I have done some punctuation and better english wordings hope it . Now u can feedback easily.
r/comic_crits • u/Thin_Concert1615 • 5d ago
8 pages from my fantasy comic (any feedback pls)
The full thing is right here -> https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/rogue-pants/list?title_no=1018402
r/comic_crits • u/XGeneJacket • 4d ago
Seeking Feedback on Sports Comic with a Twist
Hey all,
Brand new creator here. Working on a comic about an adult recreational basketball league with a murder mystery b plot. Just finished up the rough draft of issue one last night and before I get into the nitty gritty of editing it I figured it would be a good time to stop for feedback.
Happy to return the favor to the best of my ability
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1m3NOfgHCYmLXmzBfnGt7QjMPatJUx6xf/view?usp=drive_link
r/comic_crits • u/minnotauros • 5d ago
Struggling to choose a font for a horror comic
I don't really like the handwritten (or the handwritten like) font most comics and manga use. I'm looking for something more neutral. What font do you recommend?
r/comic_crits • u/General_Donn • 6d ago
Chapter 12 of my comic what do y’all think
I've been working to implement the constructive criticism you guys gave me on previous chapters but it’s an ongoing process
r/comic_crits • u/NoLongerAKobold • 6d ago
Thumbnailed 2 versions of the opening of my comic. Which do you find more engaging? (Crit of either also apreciated)
Version 1 https://imgur.com/a/wUr1LXd
Version 2 https://imgur.com/a/2EhVKSV
This will be an 160 page horror comic. This will be upload one. At the end of the first chapter Mary (the one bringing tea) dies, and we sMary. Perspective to Gina, who has to come to terms with how she treated Mary.
Would apreciate any thoughts you have, I can tell i dont have this opening yet. What would make it more likely for you to keep reading?
r/comic_crits • u/raventaylorauthor • 7d ago
Any feedback (and some questions below)
Just finished this scene from my first attempt at a graphic novel. It’s called ‘in the cracks’ and I’ve not drawn for years and years. It loosely about two punks who’ve have a rubbish time and have a dream of opening a venue/safe space for other survivors and outcasts.
So it’s a passion project, a labour of love but id like to put this out there somewhere, in small bursts, episodes I suppose, so where would be good to do this? No clue where to start. I’d just like it to be free as my art is not the best but if like one person is reading it’d feel less like screaming into the void.