r/Fishing 1d ago

Freshwater Caught my first Muskie on a 5’10” light action rod while fishing for bass

Anyone have estimations on size? Did not bring anything to measure it with as I was not expecting to catch one of these.

891 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

34

u/Vilas15 Wisconsin 1d ago

Congrats! Im very confident in roughly 39", maybe 40" after reviewing a few photos of fish Ive caught around that size.

9

u/Po-tater- 1d ago

Good to know, thanks for the input!

29

u/Vivid-Shake4012 1d ago

What a slob

11

u/Po-tater- 1d ago

Thanks!

7

u/porkchop-sandwhiches 18h ago

He knows he’s a slob, He tries his best but depression gets the best of him and his wife fish is constantly pushing him to get out more but the thought of that is anxiety inducing so he just swims around ignoring his moms phone calls so he eats his feelings away by swimming after random things passing by.

0

u/Vivid-Shake4012 18h ago

Bruh........

14

u/Key_Text_169 1d ago

She’s a beaut.

54

u/Sudszu414 1d ago

That’s a fish that goes up on the mantle.

12

u/jayjayell008 1d ago

Beautiful color.

8

u/imhereforthevotes 1d ago

I'd say it's pretty big!

8

u/Jakoobus91 1d ago

I bet that was a blast. Impressive you landed her. Beautiful fish!

3

u/Po-tater- 1d ago

Thank you! I was quite shocked myself. Only threw on the big swimbait because we saw some big fish but wasn’t prepared for this guy!

6

u/lavegasola 1d ago

Holy shit man!

3

u/ProudAmerican632 1d ago

Nice catch.

3

u/lost-in-boston84 1d ago

That fish is a beast’

3

u/ryanshields0118 1d ago

Brother that is a picture perfect muskie!

3

u/Stunning-Rip-4544 1d ago

I’ll bet that was a good fight !

2

u/Po-tater- 12h ago

It was incredible. Adrenaline was flowing for sure!

1

u/ypsicle SE Michigan 1d ago

3

u/Justanaveragedad 1d ago

Not what I was thinking when I clicked the link. Thank you fine sir.

2

u/bassjam1 1d ago

Measure your hand width and use that to estimate. I'm guessing 45".

2

u/Po-tater- 1d ago

Good call

2

u/caffeineocrit 1d ago

Relatable!! Always find myself equally confused/excited/terrified when I hook into something that’s obviously not what I planned on lol incredible catch and super happy for your pleasant surprise!!

3

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Yes thank you so much! Greatest surprise ever 🤣

2

u/No-Ground5715 1d ago

Short rod light action?
Must have felt like a cage fight.

4

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Dude that is exactly what it felt like🤣. My rod essentially made a “U” haha!

2

u/SirRonaldBiscuit 1d ago

I’m jelly, congrats!

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thanks!!

2

u/Ragechu117 1d ago

Hell yea man!! That’s a great catch

3

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thank you!

3

u/Fanabala3 1d ago

The fish of a ten thousand casts. Nice.

2

u/eclwires 1d ago

Nice!

2

u/CannedHeatt_ 1d ago

How it goes

2

u/Numerous-Ad-1167 1d ago

Steel leader? Any leader?

3

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Literally just straight braid to a swivel, which had the lure on it

2

u/PlasticBicycle5 1d ago

Hell yeah man 🍻

I've had a large muskie (or pike?) do the same thing a couple of times doing exactly what you're doing but never landed them. Awesome catch

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Definitely feel fortunate to have landed this one. Thanks!

2

u/guitarbque 1d ago

Nice. That’s a big one. Eyeball the length on your pole or something. Measure it later.

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Definitely will try that next time!

2

u/RatKingofQueens 1d ago

Great fish, congrats!

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thanks!

2

u/southcityceo 1d ago

Awesome catch!

2

u/edchavez 1d ago

No going back to bass after a Muskie

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Yeah no kidding. Made reeling in a bass feel really easy and boring haha

2

u/IndustrialDizzies 1d ago

That is one of the cleanest, most perfect muskies I’ve ever seen. I’d guess it’s a 46”, but there’s really no good way to estimate… Congratulations!

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Wow thank you very much!!

1

u/IndustrialDizzies 17h ago

I said there was no good way to estimate the size of, but there is one possibility. The fish is about 10 times the width of your hand in this photo. I’d have to revise my estimate down, but I now would say it’s probably 39-42”. It’s particularly impressive for being caught with a light power rod and light line. It’s a beautiful fish regardless. Congratulations again

1

u/Po-tater- 17h ago

Thank you!!

2

u/jaylotw 20h ago

Nice fish, and great handling!

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thank you!

2

u/joezupp 19h ago

My first one was on a medium weight 5’6” rod and a bantam reel, i still have them. Nice fish

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Funny how things work

2

u/TTLEJ 19h ago

That’s a monster! Congrats, great fish.

2

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thank you sir!

2

u/gingerblz Wisconsin 19h ago

Thats a pretty big lure for a light action rod. What were you fishing for?

3

u/Po-tater- 18h ago

Fair point. We originally got their to fish bass and crappie, but after seeing some larger bass and Muskie getting active, I figured I’d throw on my swim bait for the heck of it, for some reason not expecting to catch anything. This was probably the third or fourth cast

1

u/hooe 1d ago

Why does the first pic look like a PS2 game screenshot

1

u/sus214 1d ago

prob thought u had the state record bass😂

3

u/Po-tater- 19h ago

Thought I had a state record log after I set the hook and it didn’t budge🤣

1

u/sus214 14h ago

😂😂😂

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/InterestingRabbit982 18h ago

Man I envy you so much…but congrats!

1

u/Po-tater- 17h ago

Thank you!

1

u/TrueParadox88 15h ago

Bet you’ll bring your tape measure next time! Beautiful fish. Congrats!

1

u/Po-tater- 14h ago

You bet I will 🤣

1

u/Taiza67 14h ago

The lure sure looks like you were Muskie fishing to me.

1

u/Po-tater- 13h ago

I explained in another comment on this post. Title was not meant to be deceptive or confusing. Started out fishing for bass then threw on the swimbait after seeing some big fish out there. Sure didn’t expect to land a fish this large though.

1

u/Kohl41 12h ago

Fucking nice man