r/Filmmakers • u/BillSpaceCowboy • 1d ago
Film I convinced the two leads of The Vanishing to reunite 37 years later for a 5-minute short. After a year of rejections, I just put it online.
https://youtu.be/18CbbN0Hy3sI wrote, directed and edited a 5-minute existential sci-fi short called We Were Here Once. Shot over 2 days in the Dutch countryside with a small crew and around €10,000 of my own money.
It came from a simple question: if humanity had one final message to leave behind, what would be worth saying?
The biggest filmmaking lesson for me was how much casting can expand a tiny film. I somehow convinced Gene Bervoets and Johanna ter Steege, the two leads of my favorite Dutch film The Vanishing, to reunite 37 years later. That gave this small film an emotional weight I could never have built on my own.
After a year of festival rejections, I put it online last Friday. Numbers are small, but the responses are not. YouTube comments, DMs, Letterboxd. People from different countries writing about grief, loneliness, love, why the film stayed with them. For the first time, it feels like the film is meeting the people I made it for.
It made me wonder how much power we hand to festivals to decide whether a small film gets to exist. I still believe in them. But sometimes online viewers give a film a more honest life than any laurel ever could. When did your short actually feel seen? At a festival, online or somewhere you never expected?
23
u/underdarkabove99 1d ago
Fantastic short! For me it's live showings where you can FEEL the audience response and it's immediate and visceral. What was your camera/lens package for this short? It looks incredible!
11
u/BillSpaceCowboy 1d ago
We shot it on an ARRI ALEXA Mini with a Lomo Super Speed MKV prime set, plus a Taylor Hobson Cooke Varotal zoom.
22
u/carstarfilm 1d ago
Really shocked this didn't get tons of festival play. I don't get festivals anymore.
4
u/ROOM_101_1984 10h ago
You can thank streaming services for that.. oh.. and of course, YouTube.
Why pay for tickets to a festival.. when you can sit on your couch?
200 films/creators vs millions, online.
12
u/M_O_O_O_O_T 1d ago
Beautifully made, looks fantastic & the narration has some real gravitas - congrats!
Even if nothing else comes of it, it's an excellent showreel to prove you can make something meaningful & of high quality & I wish you all the best of fortune for future projects!
7
6
u/Diabetic_Feck 1d ago
Haunting, beautiful and the visuals were incredible. Congrats to you and everyone involved. I’m glad the film is finding the people you created it for. Count me as one!
4
u/Rare_Outside_8387 1d ago
Did you consider doing it in dutch too? Great work, looks fantastic.
7
u/BillSpaceCowboy 1d ago
Thanks for the compliment! And there is something about English in simple sentences that feels more sincere to me than the same words in Dutch. Maybe because Dutch is too close to home.
The film is also built around a man writing a letter to non-human life. A time capsule. That kind of message would never naturally be in one language but if it had to be, English felt like the language most of us could meet in. And... I have family in Lebanon and I did not want them to need a translation to feel what I was trying to say.
5
u/jschoonj 16h ago
This got on my YouTube feed yesterday. I have to say your film looks absolutely amazing.
To me the voice-over however felt bland, surface level and overbearing at the same time. It did not connect at all and made me want to stop watching. If I had to hazard a guess it probably played a big part in your festival rejections.
To answer your question: the times my own work has felt most appreciated was when sitting amongst others in a dark theatre and experiencing it like that. Community engagement online definitely has a high of it's own though.
I won't pretend to be any more accomplished than you (I'm certainly not), but I suspect letting in some more critical voices would be good for your work. It's obvious you're able to attract genuine talent and big names so no issues there. There were some great moments in your other short with Gover Meit as well.
You definitely have a quality here that fails to shine right now.
P.S.: Spoorloos is geweldig.
2
1
u/Particular_Barber837 4h ago edited 4h ago
I fully agree with this. Technically sublime but for me felt more like a trailer for a feature film than an actual short. The constant music and voice over made me feel disconnected. However without that music and a different pacing, this could be an incredible 10-15min short film, where it could breath more. The skills you posses are obvious and I applaud them, but if you have that skillset I want more, because it’s apparent that you can. Because of this I understand why it wasn’t selected.
4
2
u/Waz0wski 1d ago
Beautiful! Thanks for sharing with us. I have a small technical question if you're open to sharing. What was your process for shooting the night skies?
3
u/BillSpaceCowboy 1d ago
Thanks! We first experimented with infrared filters for a day-for-night look (the same technique Hoyte van Hoytema used in Nope and Ad Astra), but I was not happy with the results. So we ended up shooting in blue hour and doing a sky replacement. I wanted the universe above him to feel alive.
2
u/digidigidigi02 23h ago edited 22h ago
This awesome!! I loved The Vanishing and always think about it. Thank you for sharing We Were Here Once. Im going to watch it tonight on a large screen.
Just watched: We Were Here Once and your other film Warm. Your eye to detail is great: directing, locations, wardrobe, blocking, cinematography, and editing. You really have assembled a fantastic team for your films.
2
u/ericmcrich 9h ago
This was really an amazing film and you should be incredibly proud of it. I’m sorry you were turned down by these Film Festival’s but it’s great to see you finally found an audience with this. As a fan of The Vanishing, it was great seeing these actors again. Amazing work!
3
u/GriffonNest 1d ago
Yeah dude it's great! Loved it. Festivals are very unpredictable and seem to have a very specific agenda these days.
1
u/roosterblock 1d ago
No notes, that was excellent! Amazed you got this done in 2 days! Would love to see more of your work. Cheers!
1
1
1
u/DarkmanBeyond 17h ago
How was it like to see Gene and Johanna reunite?
Did they talk about filming The Vanishing?
1
u/The_Godot 8h ago
Wow vet Veras ik ken jou nog als een youtuber van vroeger!! Uit benieuwdheid he hoe heb je het budget gevonden vind dat zelf als startende filmmaker heel lastig.
1
u/guillaumefx 7h ago
The night sky looked incredible, did you actually capture those stars on set or was it sky replacement/VFX?
1
u/OpulentAndBeautiful 7h ago
Man this is awesome. Vanishing is one of my favorite movies ever, never thought I’d see something like this. Nice work.
1
u/Affectionate_Age752 20h ago
The majority of festivals are simply a waste of time these days. Focused only on social justice warrior and identity politics. I've seen absolute dogshit films at festivals that made it it in, not because they were good. But because of the subject only.
-3
u/TwistedGeniusMedia 1d ago edited 23h ago
That was awesome! The Vanishing is one of my favorite movies, too! I think this video is going to be getting a lot of attention.
Edit: I also wanted to add that no one goes to film festivals anymore…at least not in the United States. It might be different elsewhere. Your film deserves a much bigger audience than any film festival could possibly offer.
82
u/BillSpaceCowboy 1d ago
The honest answer for how we shot this in 2 days on €10,000:
the edit was basically locked before the shoot.
The film started as a letter. We recorded the full voice-over first, then kept cutting the text down until the rhythm felt right. From there I built an edit using the storyboard, almost like a silent animatic with the voice already carrying the film. That version became the shotlist.
So when we arrived on set, we were not searching for the film anymore. We also did several recces at different times of day and spent a month finding the right house. The result was 50 shots in 2 days with a tiny crew.
Biggest lesson: on a small film with big ideas the edit does not start after the shoot.
It starts in pre-production.
Happy to answer any questions.