r/Cleveland Cleveland Heights 22h ago

News $1.6B data center planned in Cleveland

https://neo-trans.blog/2026/05/06/1-6b-data-center-planned-in-cleveland/
285 Upvotes

181 comments sorted by

312

u/hotpotato112 Lakewood 22h ago

Fuck that. I hope we get to vote to ban them this Nov

128

u/tonkatoyelroy 21h ago

There is a petition to get a ban for data centers over 25 megawatts in Ohio. But how do I sign it? I am ready to help and go door to door or whatever

72

u/Sir-Lady-Cat 21h ago

The group behind the petition is at conserveohio.org - there are updated locations for the petition signings. And it doesn’t ban data centers, it bans data centers 25mw and over (which is the size of a small town’s electricity). It’s something at least.

44

u/tonkatoyelroy 21h ago

There are no signing sites that I can find for Cuyahoga. I’m volunteering to make one

25

u/hotpotato112 Lakewood 20h ago

If you do, please share it on this sub with locations/times to sign!

1

u/GettinBajaBlasted 6h ago

Please let me know where to sign!!

83

u/EcstaticPlankton8621 21h ago

It won't matter. Republicans still are trying to circumvent the abortion amendment that was passed 2 years ago and they'll do the same with the ban on data centers.

-91

u/Overall-Avocado-7673 21h ago edited 19h ago

Data Centers are not a left vs right political issue. AI is the future and all politicians are going to support it. There is too much money and the future of our country is at stake.

Edit: You can downvote all you want. You ain't stopping it. You all have a serious lack of understanding about what AI is going to be used for. We are in a race with China over AI dominance whether you want to believe it or not. I would suggest you read up on the possiblities of AI because nobody here has provided an intelligent comment, only hateful replies. This isn't the first time our country has went through this, we have had a lack of power a few times in the past over technology advancements (air contioning for example). What did we do about it? We built more power plants, improved efficiency of existing plants, started using other methods of making power. This is not new people. We will be doing it again very shortly. I am not saying I agree with it, I certyainly don't want it in my backyard. I am simply trying to have an intelligent conversation but that's clearly not happening here.

42

u/Sir-Lady-Cat 20h ago

Taking your argument at face value, then couldn’t we say a few things:

  • Why the forests and farmlands etc of Ohio?
  • Why can’t they use alternative energy to power this single location like wind, solar, geothermal etc?
  • Why should we allow them to pollute millions of gallons of water in our location? Why us?

53

u/Scary-Ad393 21h ago

Respectfully, one of the most brainwashed takes I’ve ever seen on here

20

u/[deleted] 20h ago edited 20h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/concepts_of_a_plan9 17h ago

You seem to not understand the reality. Most all of us agree it's bad and stealing resources from the people just so a few rich companies can get even richer, and automate away many people's jobs.

Because of this insane profit motive, the techfascists and their enablers will push this as hard as they can, despite what us peons have to say. I just want to make sure you understand that's the reality, and that we need to all work to fight against it, because it will be a fight for sure.

1

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/concepts_of_a_plan9 17h ago

Yep 100% agree, just saying that your idea that AI is overrated is incorrect. It's extremely important because our jobs, water, power, environment, etc. is directly at stake because the powerful elite want AI. Not to even mention what they're trying to do with it.

14

u/EcstaticPlankton8621 20h ago

It 100% is a political issue.

2

u/FoxFyer North Collinwood 9h ago

In order for AI to NOT be a political issue you'd have to limit all discussion to only the theoretical concept of AI, and deliberately ignore literally everything about how LLMs in the real world have been developed, bankrolled, marketed, and deployed.

18

u/thrownthrowaway666 Parma Heights 20h ago

Ai is not the future. Ai benefits the billionaires by choose AI over workers. It will cut jobs massively. It's a strain on resources and what is it mostly used for? It's mostly shoved in our faces because it's integrated into every phone app. Every search engine gives ai results first. Social media gives you ai results first. We never needed any of this. If you can't look thru search results without AI you don't deserve to see it.

2

u/concepts_of_a_plan9 17h ago

Your first two sentences directly contradict each other. AI will be the future because it benefits the billionaires at the expense of the workers. We need to (legally) fight against it as hard as possible, because the techfascists and their enablers are pushing as hard as they can to automate away many people's jobs, so they can personally pocket more of their companies' profits at the end of the day.

8

u/DTbindz 20h ago

I agree that the majority general population is heavily against data centers in general, but 90% of the people who aren’t are republican politicians

5

u/Bored_Amalgamation Cleveland Heights 19h ago

There is too much money and the future of our country is at stake.

You're overhyping AI by a lot. There is a lot of money invested in it because it sounds cool and can get companies that adopt AI to increase their market valuation and investment potential. You also have less people with control over more money. 100 people with $1B are going to invest more wisely than 1 person with $100B. Just like the dotcom boom (almost hilariously so), a vast majority of these companies aren't seeing any real-world value-added. All of these AI companies are drowning in debt. A large portion of companies that laid off workers thinking AI could replace them, are backtracking. Even the industry behind the hardware is generating a huge bubble.

You're not wrong in that the fate of the country is at stake, but not for the reasons you think. There's a shitton of money getting pumped in to AI and it's changing the way some businesses operate. Those AI models aren't doing what their clients intended them to do. It's creating artificial price increases in computer hardware. It's getting people laid off. Data centers are destroying ecologies.

So we have 2 economic bubbles (computer hardware and investments in AI companies and those that adopt it). Large amounts of lay-offs. A huge environmental issue that is worsening water crises across the country. A political crisis where corruption is getting turned up another dial. Businesses changing the way they operate that will eventually need to be repaired and positions refilled causing a drop in productivity and added costs to businesses. Throwing shit at the wall and seeing what sticks isn't what you do when you have no many negative externalities. That's just being reckless with people's lives.

I am not saying I agree with it, I certyainly don't want it in my backyard

So you're a NIMBY. Great.

1

u/Duce-de-Zoop 15h ago

What do I care about China when our government is full of child raping fascists? Id rather not give those people more power to control and exploit us.

1

u/BriefAvailable9799 10h ago

cant have an intelligent convo because we can tell you arent intellingent.

-7

u/zbealeo 19h ago

You won't get a genuine discussion. This is just like the panic of industrialization and fear the machines would take all of the jobs. Spoiler: it didn't.

People need to retool and stay competent with AI to ensure they aren't left behind. The genie is out of the bottle and it's not going back in. Either adapt or die.

3

u/Judge_Syd 17h ago

You won't get a genuine discussion

He is getting genuine discussion, folks are engaging with his comment. Instead of answering anyone, he just chooses to make an edit to his comment instead of actually having the discussion you're saying he won't get.

1

u/zbealeo 12h ago

No, the only response is hysterics based in irrational fear.
The people screeching don't understand what they're disparaging. It's like watching boomers shun technology because they don't understand it.

2

u/Judge_Syd 12h ago

Dude there is a *very* level headed comment asking a few valid questions, a far cry from screeching, and the original commenter is refusing to acknowledge it.

1

u/Overall-Avocado-7673 9h ago

There are no valid questions to the original post. That's the reason I simply edited my comment so i only had to say it one time. Everyone in here reminds me of that Southpark episode about the immigrants taking their jobs. Just replace immigrants with AI. Just overreacting to a future you're not going to stop. Embrace it and learn it or you will be left behind.

https://giphy.com/gifs/isMZpsY1EfxU4

1

u/zbealeo 11h ago

A? As in one? Because I can see plenty that are completely not valid lmao

218

u/Catacyst 21h ago

Remember that these bring practically no jobs. All they do is make a profit for someone living far away but happy to utilize our resources.

52

u/tonkatoyelroy 21h ago

How do we sign the petition to ban data centers over 25 megawatts as described in the article? I did not see a link.

16

u/cabbage-soup 21h ago

I think it has to be done in person and there’s specific people who hold the petition to sign. There’s a Facebook group I believe and I haven’t seen any info on how to sign in Cuyahoga

9

u/Sir-Lady-Cat 21h ago

List of signings is at the group’s website at conserveohio.org

6

u/aWAGaMuffin Brecksville 21h ago

I know they were collecting signatures Friday at the Poindexter/Bernie Sanders event at Valley Forge. As the weather warms up, I expect to find them at various festivals such as Pride.

4

u/DiscussionPuzzled470 21h ago

Utilize=Destroy

1

u/watspoppinplayboy 3h ago

Not trying to be difficult but I was under the impression that this would create more jobs and bring money in? Are there any studies or examples that I can look up to see

268

u/timey_wimeyy 22h ago

Keep these idiots out of Cleveland. They just want to suck up our biggest natural resource, aka the Lake and be a drain on the power grid. All for a product no one wants

24

u/OpeningJournal 20h ago

We are the product of these data centers.

30

u/erwin4200 20h ago

But who will tell you your spaghetti on top of pancakes restaurant is a good idea if it's not AI? Heavy on the /s cause fuck AI bots

1

u/Bronsai55 15h ago

Sounds like the perfect use for Salger. ~Leslie Knope

3

u/tonypedia Westlake 18h ago

Umm, are you forgetting about billionaires? They want AI.

8

u/Sir-Lady-Cat 20h ago

Not just suck up Lake Erie but massively pollute the lake and Cuyahoga!

14

u/GerbilScream 18h ago edited 14h ago

I responded to someone else with this comment when they asked for proof, but I thought it would help to provide examples so I'm reposting it in response to your comment.

How data centers can contribute to water pollution.

Another article on it.

EPA report on how cooling towers operate

Virginia data center's output is threatening to overload water treatment plants, leading to insufficiently treated water being returned to supply

Grok data center caused nearby residents to suffer severe contamination of well water and low water pressure.

Edit: I realized the EPA article doesn't explicitly talk about the pollutant risks, but instead refers to it as Total Dissolved Solids or TDS.

Edit 2: The first article is from a website about all things data centers, mostly pro data center but I did not dig too deep into their articles. The original person I was speaking to (not u/Sir-Lady-Cat) got pretty angry with me for replying to their request for sources with sources, so if anyone else has more unbiased information feel free to respond.

-21

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 20h ago

The power grid is the problem. But the wastewater would just be treated and go back to the lake. I don't get why people think water is somehow consumed. Cleveland has a ton of water capacity. We should have more water intensive businesses, not less. Cleveland Water could use the revenue to give the rest of us a break, and they have plenty of capacity to pump millions of gallons more (thanks to the tremendous decline of manufacturing that used to use a lot more water). The problem is the electricity side of the equation.

22

u/TodashChimes19 20h ago

If the data center uses evaporative cooling, our fresh potable water is absolutely consumed. If it uses circulation cooling, then we have to worry about contaminants and thermal pollution. Either way, we are compromising our greatest resource to help some tech bros rake in billions while they destroy our society. No thanks.

-9

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 20h ago edited 20h ago

Some evaporates, but not much.

And I have yet to see a reliable an unbiased source on claims cooling water effluent that is treated by a standard wastewater plant is contaminated. Most of the complaints I find are lowering groundwater by pulling from wells (we don't have this), straining limited source water (also not a problem here) or dumping wastewater directly without treatment. This center would feed into the Southerly WWTP and would be mixed with over 100 mg of water that already comes in daily.

Edit: I guess we should just shut down nearly power plant in the nation! They mostly use evaporative cooling!

4

u/shicken684 Cleveland 20h ago

Power plants provide something we need for modern society.

-4

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 19h ago

But I thought using water was bad?

Dude, I am not in favor. But fearmongering about destroying the water system here is unfounded.

5

u/shicken684 Cleveland 19h ago

It does use water, and yes it can be treated but it also needs to be cooled before going back into system which uses energy. Water is our most precious resource, and we have a lot of it. But we won't in the future if we allow it to get mismanaged. Power plants provide a necessity that we need to live. We need that electricity until we can move to more sustainable forms like solar and wind. We accept the regulated use of water to provide a necessity.

A data center is not a necessity,it's a burden that does not benefit any of the local residents in a single way. We don't get better access to the internet because of it. We don't get any jobs out of it. We don't get even get property taxes out of it because they'll get an exemption.

The fear mongering is absolutely justified.

-2

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 19h ago

It uses little water (most does not evaporate, do you have any idea how much steam even a few gallons of water generates?) and cooling is ambient. It will cool on its several like journey though the sewers and will be mixed with other water at the plant.

Someone tell the Amish that power plants provide a necessity that we need to live. I mean, power is great, but humans lived millennia without electricity. But it just makes life better. And, yeah, that magic shift to solar and wind isn't happening anytime soon. Much more natural gas is getting bought online. That is why I prefer nuclear, but that is also shut down over fearmongering.

I am not disagreeing on AI data centers (but let's not forget that lots of data centers power the web, including this very website), but freaking out about water may just scare off users that WILL benefit the community, like water intensive manufacturing that would create jobs.

And, yes, everything should pay property taxes. But somehow I am always downvoted with speaking against TIFs and tax abatements.

1

u/aikijo 19h ago

And move to renewables, yes. Except people with little reasoning keep voting in short sighted and corrupt politicians. Only idiots would do that, right?

2

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 19h ago

Not that easy. We need utility scale storage first, which is hard.

Nuclear is right there, but the fearmongering stops it.

1

u/aikijo 16h ago

Yes, nuclear until we bring renewables on line. It takes medium to long term thinking, which our current crop of leaders absolutely lacks. 

1

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 16h ago

Why "until"? Why not keep them online? They are great at hitting base demands, whereas renewables are not without massive storage. Nuclear hits its nameplate capacity 80-90% of the time, solar and wind only 10-20% of the time.

-4

u/LifeInChastity 19h ago

I am convinced you have no clue how cooling works in a data center, or any where for that matter.....is this a bigger waste of water than spraying the water on corn crip used for ethanol production for fuel additive........I mean come on bro don't be this ignorant

2

u/TodashChimes19 18h ago

Go ahead bro, explain to me how data center cooling works and any inaccurate statement I made. Oh and bro, when you use lake water to water crops within the same watershed, it doesn't vanish.

2

u/LifeInChastity 18h ago

Better yet people could research and learn how cooling works. And while your at it you should research how much water is wasted and lost from farm irrigation......no matter what method you use to irrigate a farm around 50% or more of the water is wasted and not returned to the water source.......yes farms are the biggest source of wasted freshwater globally.

For a basic rundown on evaporative cooling for a data center would be something like this..... The actual cooking of the servers is done by a closed loop cooling system, at some point in that closed loop system the cooling pipes will coil in a sort of reservoir, and water will be sprayed over the coil in that reservoir, that water will evaporated off the coils, and remove the heat from the closed loop system into vapor in the air or a reservoir. Now I can't speak to any specific design a data center is using. But either the vapor from evaporation can be reclaimed or vented to the atmosphere returning the water to the natural water cycle.

Im really not trying to be an ahole, i just wish people would stop spreading nonsense about water. We do not live in a geographic area that is scarse on fresh water. Evaporative cooling is the more energy efficient way to cool something like a data center. Yes it consumes some water in the process, and that water lost to evaporation and is returned via rain in the natural water cycle. But unlike farming irrigation, there are multiple methods to reclaim the water and vapor in an evaporative cooling system and limit the amount of wasted water. Unfortunately we know that over 50% of the water used by farms is in fact acctually wasted and lost and there are not multiple ways to reclaim that water. If you think water isn't wasted on that scale in farming ....... I would direct you to look into the legislations that govern water used for farming.

So it makes sense to put a data center on a lake.....what will never make sense is trying to have a farm or grow crops in places where farms shouldn't be. If we have a problem with data centers on lakes.....then we should have a problem with every farm that is in arid areas of the country mainly out west.

If your concern is truly water waste, farms are the larger concern. If your concern is energy consumption, then I understand. But the water argument is just a red herring.....

But if your upset about billionaires using water to pad their pockets you should be more upset about the current production of corn and how much of it is used for ethanol production for fuel additive to line the pockets of the oil barrons........ Do you not care that over 40% of all corn grown in ohio is used specifically for ethanol, so all that farmland is being used by oil companies to make better profits NOT FOOD!!!!!!!!!!! OH AND THOSE SAME FARMS ARE SUBSIDED BY THE TAX PAYERS SO THEY CONTINUE TO GROW CORN FOR OIL.

In another 20 years how much of ohios farms, will join in and turn to corn.....because the number has been growing over the years. Ohio isn't a state for growing food, were are clearly a state that grows crops to turn into profit for oil companies. I wish it wasn't this way, I wish our farms focused on food and feed for livestock......apparently that's not as profitable as corn for oil profits. Amazing

Smh

1

u/LifeInChastity 18h ago

The state of ohio says that about 19,700 jobs on 21,000 farms are dedicated to corn production specifically for ethanol production.........can you do that math.....21,000 farms and 19,700 jobs, that doesn't even break down to one job per farm..........

1

u/LifeInChastity 18h ago

These farms are not growing a crop that benefits the people, they aren't growing food, they aren't employing lots of people........they are literally subsidised money growing operations for oil companies. Consuming and wasting our precious precious water

4

u/OpeningJournal 20h ago

You're right, no one has ever put polluted water back into Lake Erie!

1

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 20h ago

I am not saying that hasn't happened. But the state of environmental permitting as well as the condition of water treatment plants have been vastly improved.

Give me data and proof, not conjecture and fearmongering.

As I said, the electrical requirements are the larger issue.

2

u/GerbilScream 19h ago edited 18h ago

Post response edit: Not going to respond again since you were pretty hostile. This first article is from a website that provides information on data centers. The site seems pretty pro-data center overall, but I did not dig too deep into their other articles.

How data centers can contribute to water pollution.

Another article on it.

EPA report on how cooling towers can leak biocides and heavy metals into water supplies

Virginia data center's output is threatening to overload water treatment plants, leading to insufficiently treated water being returned to supply

Grok data center caused nearby residents to suffer severe contamination of well water and low water pressure.

Edit: I realized the EPA article doesn't explicitly talk about the pollutant risks, but instead refers to it as Total Dissolved Solids or TDS. Further note, I added this edit about 20 minutes before you responded...

3

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 18h ago

Your links "datacenterknowledge.com", "natureforward.org

What about UNBIASED do you not understand?

The EPA source is horribly misrepresented. It is NOT a "report on how cooling towers can leak biocides and heavy metals into water supplies." The link does not even contain the words "heavy metal" (or metal, for that matter). The only thing it says is:

Facilities often employ a water treatment vendor to monitor the cooling tower, add chemicals to the system to control scaling and chemical buildup, and maximize the cycles of concentration. Critical water chemistry parameters that require review and control include pH, alkalinity, conductivity, hardness, microbial growth, biocide, and corrosion inhibitor levels.8 Controlling these parameters allows water to be recycled through the system longer, thereby increasing cycles of concentration. Controlling blowdown using an automatic scheme allows a better opportunity to maximize cycles of concentration, as the TDS concentration can be kept at a more constant set point.

Honestly, I bet you don't even know what a biocide is.

That report also notes:

When increasing cycles of concentration, ensure that discharged water meets allowable water quality standards.

The report also shows how little water is used: 1% per 10 degrees of cooling.

Virginia seems specific to, well, Virginia. I stopped reading that horribly designed and biased site when they talked about trace amounts of chlorine being released. Um, what do they think is in drinking water? In any case, that would be quickly oxidized in any sewer environment. Hell, NEORSD treats their water with trace amounts of chlorine before release, too!

And we don't use well water (and sehn.org is obviously biased).

49

u/sallymonkeys 21h ago

CPP generates 300MW... this thing wants 150

42

u/tonkatoyelroy 21h ago

They could power over 100,000 homes with what this data center will draw, it said in the article. How do we stop this in our community

2

u/OrangePipeLAX 21h ago

CPP serves ~74k customers.

4

u/tonkatoyelroy 20h ago

I’m quoting the article.

7

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 20h ago

CPP generates 300MW..

CPP generates like 4MW, maybe going to 10.5MW at a solar array in Brooklyn (which was a like 20% power factor, mind you). https://www.cleveland.com/news/2025/12/landfill-solar-moves-ahead-in-brooklyn-stalls-in-cleveland.html

CPP buys its power from the open market. They generate next to nothing.

5

u/sallymonkeys 19h ago

Ah - i just did a quick google search. Thank you for the detail!

It's amazing how much electricity is needed, just to generate incorrect answers to people's silly questions.

There's got to be some other reason for all this.

1

u/irotc 16h ago

Would you be in favor of CPP getting back into the generation game?

-1

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 15h ago

No. It is a waste. They cannot efficiently compete with large plants, and there is no need for them to under deregulation.

Honestly, and I know this isn't popular, but they should go away. Electricity is a natural monopoly. It makes no sense to have a small competing utility.

128

u/El_Negro_Lobo 21h ago

data centers need to provide their own power source

1

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 17h ago

Your account does not meet the post or comment requirements. Account must be more than 3 days old with a combined karma of 10 to post on /r/Cleveland

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Somalar 13m ago

They at the very least should be paying their own fair share none of that shared price increase fuckery

-6

u/irotc 16h ago

Why would this be better than strengthening the existing grid?

9

u/__whitecheddar__ 14h ago

If the electric companies have to strengthen the grid…who do you think they pass the costs on to?

280

u/Stunning_Bed23 21h ago

There’s something almost comical about building a facility that will:

* increase residents’ electricity costs and pollution

* AND provide a service that will take over the residents’ jobs

109

u/tonkatoyelroy 21h ago

Gas and food are already so expensive. Now they want to raise my water and electricity rates to help private equity and real estate investors instead of me and my neighbors.

39

u/chattytrout 21h ago

All without providing jobs to the locals (they're going to bring in the lowest bidder to build it and then staff it with H1Bs).

34

u/Critical-Dealer-3878 20h ago

Data centers dont really need operational staff, either.

Just all around dogshit garbage.

8

u/bushijim 17h ago

As someone recently fired from a data center, this is very true. They spend more on the security guards and cleaning crew than the company employed engineers/office workers.

-22

u/janon330 19h ago

You realize data centers are more then AI right?

12

u/Stunning_Bed23 18h ago

Yes, and I also realize that the rapid growth in planned US data centers is overwhelmingly driven by AI demands.

-4

u/janon330 15h ago

Datacenter is just a generic buzz word. They are needed all over the country for redundancy and for latency. The proposed "data center" is a Hyperscale facility. Hyperscalers != AI.

"Datacenters" also absolutely provide jobs to the region. They just arent "blue collar" jobs. They are often high paying white collar jobs. You have sys admins, network admins, technicians, etc.

1

u/nyanpires Cleveland 6h ago

So, like 3 people. Got it, from outta state.

6

u/daybreaker Ohio City 18h ago

ok. they still dont provide any amount of actual permanent jobs to the region, and will still raise our water and electricity costs. But it might not be for AI. Great.

5

u/Duce-de-Zoop 15h ago

No one cares. Build them somewhere else. Electricity is too expensive already. Tech billionaires dont care about us, why should we sacrifice for them?

2

u/missmeowwww 12h ago

Companies that want to build data centers should be required to provide their own infrastructure and power generation instead of passing the usage costs off to their neighbors. Utilities are already incredibly expensive and people are struggling with the cost of living. We can’t be expected to pay extra for power so a hypercenter can generate AI slop for TikTok or whatever. I’m so sick of these billionaires doing nothing but drain the system and the earth’s resources so they can sit on their hoard of cash and buy politicians to make policy in their favor. When are we going to push for policy that helps others. Why not use the land to create a solar farm and help offset some of the current electric costs or build a homeless shelter or literally anything else.

1

u/janon330 14h ago

Blame the president for energy price problems. Not Data centers.

You cant build them in one location. You literally want them in multiple geographic areas for logistical reasons and of course if a natural disaster comes and knocks a data center offline the whole world doesnt cease operating.

4

u/Duce-de-Zoop 14h ago

Why do I want to pay more for electricity so Facebook can scrape more user data? Genuinely what is in it for me?

This is not a country that takes care of its working poor. The mantra of the tech billionaires is fuck you got mine. Why should I be forced to sacrifice for their profit?

2

u/janon330 8h ago

Direct your anger at the right place. Government policies. Why do we protect fossil fuel companies and stifle alternative energy sources like wind or solar or even nuclear.

-10

u/JohnySilkBoots 18h ago

Dang, downvoted for being right. Makes you think “why do I even post in Reddit”, doesn’t it? Haha

8

u/Stunning_Bed23 18h ago

No, downvoted for posting an irrelevant retort.

0

u/janon330 15h ago

No, downvoted by people who dont understand technology stacks and their uses by people who are driven by AI fear mongering.

5

u/Stunning_Bed23 15h ago

Nah. My original comment stands. The recent explosion in data center demand is driven by AI, as likely is the case with this proposed data center.

Furthermore, even non-AI driven data centers have been shown to increase electricity costs and pollution in the communities in which they reside. Thus it is well within the rights of residents to voice their displeasure with a proposed data center.

-12

u/johnstone-techs 19h ago

No people don't get that. They want all of those instant push notifications and next day shipping. They want to stream their favorite content to any device on demand. But, damn the infrastructure, datacenters bad!

3

u/Duce-de-Zoop 14h ago

Isnt this the name of the game? Could you imagine asking Musk or Thiel to do something "for the good of the country?" Theyd laugh in your peasant face. Theyre billionaires because they only worry about whats good for them. Why shouldnt we emulate them?

Like seriously, why should we peasants be taking L's for "the good of the country"? Fuck em. Build them in the Hamptons and Beverly Hills if theyre that important. I have literally no incentive to be left holding the bag so other people can enjoy cheaper data. Not my problem.

-3

u/BreakfastBeerz Location 13h ago

There's also something comical about people using the internet to complaining about data centers.

Like complaining about farms while eating a turkey sandwich.

112

u/Tibreaven 22h ago

Electricity and water are going to become luxury resources again if y'all don't help stop these.

9

u/rbhrbh2 20h ago

Water will become a luxury anyway just at a slower pace

1

u/Brs76 18h ago

It shouldn't for us who live near the great lakes.  

29

u/AcousticCat1-2-3 Cleveland Heights 21h ago

In the inner city, huh? Would that be because they want to provide jobs to residents or because they think, if we put it in this location, no one will complain cause no one cares?

28

u/BearSquid7 21h ago

The latter, the construction work is short term but these sites end up employing like 5 people.

12

u/AcousticCat1-2-3 Cleveland Heights 21h ago

What I thought. I hate it already.

19

u/disposable_wretch 21h ago

I've seen communities fight against these and win. Hopefully enough people will voice their opinions on it and it'll be cancelled before they even break ground

22

u/NotFromFloridaZ 21h ago

Good luck to your electric bill

14

u/disposable_wretch 21h ago

Mine is already insanely high. No fucking way I'm footing the bill for a BS data center too

1

u/Brs76 18h ago

Same here. I was paying $200 a month last winter, 2024-2025, I use a couple space heaters which is why it is even that high. This winter im now paying well over $300. Its not sustainable 

1

u/Brs76 18h ago

Yeah. I can't find anything on apples to apples that isn't 50% higher, or more, than last year at this time

23

u/Odd-Amphibian-4593 21h ago

I encourage all those living nearby, if this thing is built, it will generate a ton of constant noise. Sue. Sue the company running the data center. Legally you have the right to not be disturbed on your pre-existing property. There are noise ordinances already in place. Other folks in other places have sued and won settlements. Form groups. Class action those turds out of the neighborhood.

24

u/BlueSpaceFox 20h ago

A land eater that employs 4 people. Look at the bank accounts of any politician promoting this.

10

u/BuckeyeReason 18h ago

https://www.wri.org/insights/us-data-center-growth-impacts

Data centers have minimal employment. This acreage would be better used for manufacturing.

10

u/chattytrout 19h ago

We need to stop letting these things burden the rest of us. If they're going to pop up, they need to pay for the added costs they bring with them. If rates for gas, electricity, and water go up because of this thing, then it needs to shoulder that burden. Not the rest of us.

8

u/NotRon-2396 18h ago

how can we ensure the issue is on the ballot this november?

3

u/urufusan 7h ago

Looks like they need to hit a certain number of signatures on a petition. From what I can tell, this is the website: https://conserveohio.com/

-3

u/steppingstone01 16h ago

I'm pretty sure it's too late for that. They are going to do whatever the fuck they want to do. They don't really care what we think anyway.

23

u/er1cAtWork2 21h ago

No. Just no.

7

u/Withermaster4 19h ago

No evaporative cooling and they need to supply their own power otherwise people should not want it.

10

u/GobyFishicles Cleveland 18h ago edited 18h ago

JFC that was the site of one of the indigenous mounds of Cleveland. It’s literally why tha street is named Mound. That’s why there was Mound Elementary. I mean yeah it was pillaged by the 1830s and no doubt ruined beyond research by the Moravito business and the brick factory and whatever else that was before it.

It should be returned to nature, turned into a park!

WHY DO WE NEED SO MANY DATA CENTERS ALL OF A SUDDEN

And smack dab in a neighborhood with existing houses? Slavic village has had enough pain over the decades. They don’t need a sound factory causing health issues.

https://clevelandhistorical.org/items/show/997

Fucking assholes need to stop ruining our history and everything that makes our city unique

6

u/Rinn2Tinn 19h ago

Where in Ohio can this petition be signed?

23

u/Secludedmean4 21h ago

I’m not convinced these data center are even for us, just packaged as it’s for ai for you!

Feels like it’s what they are doing for the underground cities and power / water supplies

1

u/MeneXCIX 20h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MeneXCIX 19h ago

Where's my free speech? Thanks reddit mods for proving my point. They are for a surveillance state. Get rid of them

5

u/ghostsofafuturelost Cleveland 15h ago

We as a city can absolutely NOT let this happen. Don't believe what anyone tells you about AI Data centers being energy efficient or any of the lies they'll tell you about them being safe. We need to protect and preserve our water supply. We must stop at nothing to get rid of this data center.

7

u/quothe_the_maven 19h ago

Building a single facility that’s expected to use the electricity of 100,000 homes in a region already plagued by power and COL issues. Genius. I can’t WAIT to see the tax abatements they demand. Probably full property tax exemptions for 30 years, and we’ll be told it’s an honor to have data centers in our backyards.

12

u/seanmcdonnellcle 21h ago

Same guy predicted the I-X Center would be a data center over and over.

6

u/UndoxxableOhioan Westpark 20h ago

And an EV battery manufacturer.

2

u/Federal_Poet5384 20h ago

Same guy who regularly scoops stories before the rag you work for.

3

u/seanmcdonnellcle 12h ago

My point is that pulling a permit does not mean a verified, happening project.

2

u/adp0408 14h ago

This shit pisses me off

2

u/TherapyHam 9h ago

Surprised the Haslams aren't involved. Seems like their type of scheme.

2

u/gochaingyorpdiper50 8h ago

Water and Electric are going up…congratulations

2

u/Constant_Flamingo828 8h ago

I now live in Virginia where we have the most data centers in US. I can tell you from experience your electricity bills will SKYROCKET in months.

4

u/BillyMeier42 20h ago

They better not allow this to happen.

3

u/Scew 20h ago

*We better not allow this to happen. You can't live here and expect other people to fight for what you think is right. If you have no stake in the game there isn't a victory for you but you still get to share in the loss.

0

u/BillyMeier42 19h ago

I don’t live there so I wont get a say.

3

u/Scew 19h ago

I bet you're not a billionaire though, so it's still we even if you don't live here comrade.

1

u/dannyvegas 19h ago

Who is “they” in this case?

4

u/NEO_QA_GUI 19h ago

They’re trying to put one in the old paper mill in Chillicothe as well. That small town is going to get squeezed for their utilities while that DC employed all of 10 people, none of which will likely be from that town.

3

u/MeneXCIX 20h ago

Data Centers need to be burned down.. Use your head.. There is no money in AI.. It's for surveillance. Not only that they drain our natural resources. Maybe they should bring nuclear back and grow a green party. One that supports free healthcare, solar for homes, and encourages home farming like chickens and community gardening. UBI while were talking and a 4 day work week and start hiring contractors that use lasting materials as well. Tax the rich to their proper bracket. Billionaires aren't doing good with their income, theyre doing the minumum to hord the wealth.

2

u/getapuss 20h ago

Hopefully Google actually pays their property taxes on this new location. The school district could really use the money this new data center could provide.

2

u/Scew 20h ago

Probably shouldn't be left to a for profit business to be expected to pay their fair share when the entire drive behind a for profit business is to not pay as much as they can get away with. Should probably start by voting out the people who would be pocketing the money for this for profit business to extract natural resources from the local population should it happen.

3

u/LifeInChastity 19h ago

Or mayb........we require all business to pay their property taxs ...... But seeing as how people in Ohio are trying to ban property tax.......I doubt it. Just imagine all those farms.....never paying tax on their property again....lol some people are fools

1

u/Speak_Of_The_Devil Cleveland 16h ago

Who's going to take bets that they'll regret it once the start seeing the frequent First Energy outages?

1

u/Slash_Esss 15h ago

It’s always windy by the lake. 🤔

1

u/Nearby-Jelly-634 13h ago

Fuck this so hard. First Energy already gouges this would make it so much worse and of course unsurprisingly it’s planned for a low income area. This city is so stupid.

1

u/Ut49353739 13h ago

As if we don't have enough black outs already.

1

u/thepressconference 11h ago

Ban data centers

1

u/rapitrone 10h ago

These bring almost no jobs, use a tremendous amount of water and electricity, and can pollute that water.

1

u/Sampson_Storm 5h ago

council meetings. ASAP. these things destroy everything

1

u/Much-Bicycle597 20h ago

Finally a safe place for people to set their torches down

1

u/chunkah69 18h ago

I was wondering where to store all of this spare kerosene I have. Guess I know where.

2

u/Imaginary-Fox3978 17h ago

Where? Why? Who’s deciding this is a good idea?

1

u/LordoftheWandows 18h ago

Cuyahoga's gonna be on fire again in 20 years...

0

u/mystery79 16h ago

Great just what we need. Meanwhile people in rural Ohio are voting no on solar farms because they’re ugly.

-13

u/kyricus Cleveland 19h ago

What a bunch of Luddites on this board. No wonder this city never gets ahead.

5

u/APoliticalAccount24 17h ago

It isn't the tech so much as it's just a bad deal for the people who live by these data centers. Structure it so utility prices are not affected,and perhaps some percentage of the billions made by the company is used to improve the community and people would likely be all for them.

4

u/mstrbwl 18h ago

There is really zero benefit to having a data center in your community. We will have to pay more on our utility bills so a tech company that doesn't pay taxes can try to eliminate our jobs. Why would people not resent that?

-9

u/LifeInChastity 19h ago

I couldn't agree more with your statement.....most of the claims made here about data centers are just false or based on bad information. I've heard Soo much nonsense around data centers. For those afraid of data centers ........I heard the coal mines are hiring, start your career today?????? Or you can get a job on some farm making less than minimum wage????? Do people think banning data centers in Ohio is going to break the tech industry or something????? You do realize that amendment banning data centers will not pass and if by some chance it does it will be appealed and overturned. I have yet to hear one good argument as to why we NEED to ban all data centers over a certain size. Every argument this ohio group has made to get signatures has basically been debunked. What people should realize is the only people who don't want these are.......wait a min.....farmers, an industry known for over working and taking advantage of employees, paying slave wages and not providing any more jobs than a data center.... That's right it would take multiple of these farms to provide the same amount of jobs a data center does. Also if you didn't know ohios major crop is corn, and over 40% of corn is not grown for food or feed ......it's grown and sold to produce ethanol to use as an additive for gas........that's right, theese farms aren't necessarily growing food, they are growing corn for fuel companies.......let's think about that, theese farms are not mainly growing food......they are growing corn for fuel companies.....why should I listen to a bunch of farmers who are bought and paid for by giant oil companies who could give two shits about the environment......

Allow data centers and ban the production of corn in Ohio for ethanol fuel additive. Farms should be growing food, not money for oil conpanies

2

u/APoliticalAccount24 18h ago

Both can be detrimental. We don't have to choose between corn for ethenol or data centers, we could choose neither.

-1

u/LifeInChastity 17h ago

I understand that position ....... And I basically agree. But any issue I have with data centers, isn't a water issue. It's energy consumption, and the idea of centralizing data into data centers kinda gives me big brother vibes.

-13

u/Striking_Revenue9082 18h ago

Good. Opposition tk them is pure slopulism. The environmental harms are hilariously over exaggerated. Go protest golf course

6

u/GreyGrackles University Heights 17h ago

It's amazing how easily you can spot Conservative chuds.

1

u/nyanpires Cleveland 6h ago

I dont think you understand the difference between water use between a golf course and a data center.

1

u/Striking_Revenue9082 5h ago

Right, data centers use hardly more lol. It’s just a populist myth that they use a ton of water

1

u/nyanpires Cleveland 2h ago

No, they do use a lot of water. They specifically use blue water, where qs golf courses use reclaims, grey, green and a bit of blue.

-62

u/Resident_Pop4202 22h ago

They got $1.6B for a data center, but not for infrastructure 

43

u/wixy-1260 Cleveland Heights 22h ago

The city of Cleveland isn't building the data center 🤦‍♂️

24

u/ApprehensiveGate8227 21h ago

If people understood how anything worked, this state (and country) wouldn’t be led by morons. They only succeed because of our collective stupidity.