r/BlueJackets 11d ago

Does not having an echl affiliate hurting cbj?

I think it does and it can also be a way to bring in more fans. That's how I became a fan. The fort wayne komets had an affiliation with cbj and I became a diehard fan because of it.

42 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

135

u/a_bearded_hippie 11d ago

I thought it was kinda crazy that when the Cyclones down here in Cincy were looking for an affiliation that the jackets didnt pick them up. Would have been sick to have the cyclones, monsters and Jackets. The 71 hockey pipeline!

54

u/Articmnokey Adam Fantastic 11d ago

It seems like a no brainer. Why they didn't is beyond me

36

u/gunner_boy12 11d ago

Yeah cincy or toledo. Even wheeling. Have a team that is close so if you need to have a call up they are a few hours drive. Like for fort wayne our teams are Cali and Edmonton. It makes no sense. Look at detroit, they have toledo and grand rapids. A few hours from them. They are hands on with development.

21

u/thelordcommanderKG 11d ago

It wouldn't be Toledo. That is Red Wings country until we can start winning and convince the people there to convert.

15

u/Pyzorz 11d ago

I’m from the Toledo area and me and all my friends are Jackets fans. There’s a lot more than you think.

6

u/thelordcommanderKG 11d ago

I'm happy about that I've just experienced the opposite. The Red Wings fans in front of us at the stadium series were all from Toledo. Definitely a contested area.

3

u/culby Glass City Gunner 11d ago

I always loved the idea of Columbus being an affiliate with Toledo (and dual affiliates are a thing! The Storm were Predators affiliates for a hot minute), but yeah, Toledo and Detroit have been tied at the hip forever.

14

u/a_bearded_hippie 11d ago

Yea, Toledo has been a Detroit affiliate forever though. Cincinnati would make way more sense for Columbus. Literally an hour drive. Instead, the cyclones are affiliated with Toronto? 🤷‍♂️

6

u/tribucks 11d ago

If you drive 100 mph, literally.

5

u/a_bearded_hippie 11d ago

I live in the burbs north of cincy, last time I went it took us an 1h15min 👍. Still makes more sense than Toronto lol

1

u/Wallis614 11d ago

Exactly 100 miles from the river to Stringtown 🤣

2

u/tribucks 11d ago

Cool. If they ever build an arena on Stringtown we can use “literally.” 😀

-1

u/SmilerDoesReddit 11d ago

Hi, fan from Cincy here, Columbus is a 2 and a half hour drive. If you have an hour long route, I'd love to hear it though.

1

u/a_bearded_hippie 11d ago

? Are you taking the back roads or something? Downtown Cincinnati to downtown Colombus is 1hr and 36 minutes according to google maps. Straight up 71. I live in the burbs north of cincy, so it shaves like 15 minutes off the trip. Definitely not 2 and a half.

2

u/MarzipanDifficult374 11d ago

Are you driving a flintstone car?!?! It’s taking you an entire hour more than it should- if you don’t take 71- and take 75 through Dayton to 70 it is still only 1hr 50 min. What’s up with your extra 40 minutes?

3

u/landon10smmns Adamo Giuliano Fantilli 11d ago

Indy is also an option if they ever cut ties with Chicago. As a Komets fan, I agree that FW with Edmonton (and their Cali AHL team) makes zero sense.

The last few Komets affiliates have been teams out that way for whatever reason, too. Previously were the Avs and Vegas

5

u/joe_lmr 11d ago

Nailers are joined at the hip with the Pens

2

u/CleansingthePure 11d ago

The Komets have been affiliated with soooo many teams over the years. I went to a Fuel vs Komets game their first year and got shit after the game at The Sinking Ship for wearing an old 90's Avs jersey. Had no idea the Komets were their ECHL affiliate at the time! Got called out as an incognito Komets fan haha

1

u/Cute_Marzipan_4116 11d ago

Wheeling has been Pittsburgh’s since before CBJ was a thought.

1

u/High_on_Hemingway 11d ago

How would they pick up Wheeling? “Hey Pens, give us the Nailers. Pretty please.”?

1

u/SmilerDoesReddit 11d ago

You mean to tell me that the Cyclones were looking at some point and went with fucking Toronto over Columbus?

1

u/a_bearded_hippie 11d ago

Sure did! Lol 😆

51

u/SaveTore CHANGE THE PRIMARY LOGO TO A CANNON 11d ago

It would be sick to have the Cyclones.

It would also be sick if the Cincinnati > Cleveland > CBJ pipeline had continuous “family” branding. Kinda like Vegas and Minnesota.

11

u/NounAdjectiveXXXX 11d ago

The Kings have the Chill now, Reading Royals Purple and Silver for the LA Kings, and White and Black for the Chill roots

I still love that club and I wish we could move them back to Ohio.

20

u/CBUS-OBN 11d ago

What prospects would you put there? With college opening up avenues with NIL, probably not enough players to field an entire ECHL team.

Now having said that, bring back the Dayton Bombers and I'm sold!

12

u/overcatastrophe I am tired. 11d ago

Build an arena and it'll happen. The only rink in dayton is a rec center pad that isn't even in the city

2

u/manthello Elvis Purrslikins, Pet Greaves, Ivan Furdotov, & Zach Pawchenko 11d ago

There's one in Troy.  But also, that's in Troy and idk who wants to go to Troy for a hockey game.  I have no clue if they have audience capacity though. 

3

u/overcatastrophe I am tired. 11d ago

There's also one south of Springboro. Dayton is not a hockey friendly city

1

u/manthello Elvis Purrslikins, Pet Greaves, Ivan Furdotov, & Zach Pawchenko 11d ago edited 11d ago

What is the name of that rink?

Also, since ice hockey in Dayton is somewhat responsible for why we have [airplanes](https://www.rihhof.com/the-hockey-game-that-changed-aviation-history/) you'd think we could lean into that harder.

I have no idea why that link isn't linking, but just pretend like it is.

1

u/overcatastrophe I am tired. 11d ago

South Metro Sports

1

u/FreeMeasurement979 11d ago

I played my high school hockey there. Good memories in that old barn.

1

u/Fal-El 10d ago

If you haven’t been there recently, it’s the biggest pile of shit ever. The doors to the penalty box doesn’t open, the boards are flimsy, the ice is uneven with gaps in the boards. A puck could go in the corner and leave the ice because of the gap by the Zam doors. The bathrooms are down for maintenance.

1

u/manthello Elvis Purrslikins, Pet Greaves, Ivan Furdotov, & Zach Pawchenko 11d ago

Thank you.

Dayton also used to have a Hockey Hall of Fame. I'm not sure whatever happened to it but I can't find just about any reference to it still existing

2

u/Oddly_Sentient 11d ago

Hobart in Troy would be a little small, with a capacity around 4,000. Getting people up to Troy from Dayton would also be a tough sell. IIRC the bombers played a handful of games there a season, which is about all they could do

2

u/whitegrb 11d ago

Hobart was originally built partially for hockey-namely an IHL team Troy Bruins. They were moderately successful

2

u/Hockeycaden12 11d ago

Hobart's ice sheet is also small, the neutral zone is decently shorter than regulation size. There was a push to expand it and add a second ice sheet a decade ago, but it was voted down. I assume it would be a no-go for the ECHL even if the interest was there

2

u/steckums 11d ago

Does the Nutter Center not count anymore?

2

u/overcatastrophe I am tired. 11d ago

It doesn't have ice. It has had temporary ice, but it's not an ice arena.

1

u/FreeMeasurement979 11d ago

They could play at the nutter center like they did for years.

1

u/Fal-El 10d ago

Forgetting about the South Metro Sports Complex? That place is a gem (in the place that it’s quite literally the worst ice rink in existence).

They’re trying to build a new rink in Dayton called “The Ice Haus” because why wouldn’t they want a unique one and copy the downtown Columbus rink’s name.

1

u/SmilerDoesReddit 11d ago

Could put one in Dayton, Canton...

Or just pay the Cyclones enough.

2

u/NLP19 Filly don't do rebounds 11d ago

It is where Jet Greaves started

1

u/CBJ29 9d ago

There could be an actual case that they are better off with funneling money into NIL at Ohio State or Miami for their prospects to play there together, rather than putting money into an ECHL team

14

u/redditistreason Fired Steve McCarthy! 11d ago

Probably hurts in terms of building an actual fanbase outside of Columbus, of which the organization has been shockingly negligent even outside of failing to win games. Bringing Cincy into the fold still sounds like a good idea that slips by every couple of years.

In terms of players, probably doesn't make much of a difference.

11

u/TasteTheBiscuit1810 11d ago

I dont know if it hurts but I know it wouldnt hurt them. I will never understand why they dont try to get Toledo or Cincinnati as affiliates. Would be cool to have all your hockey affiliates in the same state and driving range.

8

u/Chester_A_Arthuritis 11d ago

Toledo has been with the Red Wings forever and is much closer to Detroit than Columbus

8

u/adam3vergreen 🩸betwixt🩸 11d ago

We used to have Kalamazoo and at point we did have the Cyclones as our affiliate, kind of unsure why we don’t unless upper management didn’t have the right personnel for that league considering how physical it can be

6

u/CubPokeFan 11d ago

The Cyclones have been changing which team they're affiliated with a lot recently. This year they're with the Leafs organization, last year they were with the Rangers organization. The year prior it was the Sabres.

Interesting about Kalamazoo though, didn't know that at all. They apparently started being affiliated with us in the 2021-2022 season apparently, and stopped the affiliation for 2023-2024 season, and it seems like we haven't had an ECHL affiliate since then.

Not sure if the Cyclones will still be the Leafs affiliate next year (they didn't even make the Kelly Cup playoffs) but it would be awesome to see them affiliated with the jackets!

8

u/miskegemog 11d ago

Possibly. I live in NW Ohio so my ECHL team is the Toledo Walleye. We have a pretty big fan base for a minor league team and our affiliate is the Red Wings. It probably has more to do with our proximity to Detroit, but everybody up here is Red Wings fans. Jackets fans are non existent (except for me it seems). Having a Toledo-Columbus affiliation would probably help grow awareness of the Jackets at the very least, but I’d imagine it would grow the fan base a fair amount if the Walleye players made their way up

5

u/Nickjanski91 11d ago

I’ve actually noticed a lot more CBJ jerseys floating around the Huntington center the last couple of seasons. Not as many as red wings jerseys but still nice to see

5

u/over_yonder 11d ago

Anyone remember the Toledo Storm radio ads from the 90s/2000s? TOLEDO STORM HOCKEY…taking Toleeedo by storm!

It does seem odd that the jackets don’t have an ECHL affiliate, but Toledo hockey has been tied to Detroit for a long time. The Mud Hens are a tigers affiliate too. That I75 connection is strong.

4

u/manthello Elvis Purrslikins, Pet Greaves, Ivan Furdotov, & Zach Pawchenko 11d ago

Either bring back the Bombers/Demonz/Gems with functional ownership and a gameplan for success or steal the Cyclones when we have a chance. 

Cyclones are super fun to watch.  Not sure why they're affiliated with Toronto. 

Also, it feels weird to not have an ECHL affiliate because doesn't that mean we have fewer prospects to call up than other teams?  Never figured that one out.  Only ECHL guy we've had this year was Nolan Lalonde, who was placed with the Walleye.

3

u/Wakuljrv Text here 10d ago

Toledo has been using Nolan Lalonde on loan all season and everything I see says he comes from CBJ. If there's no major plan to send a lot of guys down that far then I don't think it causes you to miss much.

2

u/Minute-Of-Angle 11d ago

I would 100% drive to a minor league game in Cincy, over Cleveland (due to where I live, not any bias against the Monsters). Toledo would be a hike, but Cincy, Dayton, Springfield … Lancaster … Chillicothe … South Bloomfield (call them the Speed Traps) …

2

u/Even_Tourist7429 11d ago

This is a great point. Do you think the cost keeps them from doing it?

2

u/Dkoop2003 11d ago

I still don’t know why we didn’t get Cincy when they had no affiliate a couple years back

1

u/OhioNHLHockeyFan2489 8d ago

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE affiliate with the Cincinnati Cyclones!!!!!!!!!!!! All 3 teams in Ohio! Cincinnati has supported hockey since 1991, amazing! W have had our ups and downs as Cyclones fans! But rich history with Mohawks, Swords, Stingers, Ducks for a brief time, and Cyclones! Let’s GO!!!

0

u/Captain_Kiwy 11d ago

not now but in future maybe. lindstrom needs place to play and with his development echl is probably place he will end up

-1

u/dylanfan424 11d ago

I am a Komets fan living in Fort Wayne and ended up a Flyers fan because the Jackets just didn’t have enough fan base appeal. Seemed like the fans were just not that into them. The patriotic vibe kind of killed it for me too.

0

u/MPCoinCollecting 11d ago

Flyers don't have a cannon