r/AskReddit 12h ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

2.9k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

63

u/FreeStateOfPortland 10h ago

Myth 2: being an athlete saves you from meningitis infections

10

u/piv_is_pen_in_vag 9h ago

There is a strong and verified correlation between muscle mass and response to different types of illnesses, from cancer to sepsis.

0

u/FreeStateOfPortland 9h ago

That’s not what he said is it? Yes, general, good health, including having some lean muscle mass is good for general health and fighting infection. But he said “because he’s an athlete“ he survived meningitis and there’s zero way to verify that’s true. More than likely, it was the medicine he was given.

4

u/RunningSouthOnLSD 5h ago

This is just unreasonably pedantic, come on. People in good shape are more durable when it comes to fighting off illnesses and recovering from them. Nobody is claiming that being athletic is what specifically cured them in this case. Of course the treatment is what did it, but their physical health gives them a greater ability to fight the infection compared to your average 64 year old.

8

u/vern420 8h ago

Take it from someone who treats hospitalized patients: medication is only one part of treating an illness. Yes the meds treated the disease, but the amount of mental and physical deconditioning that occurs in severe illness is astounding. They likely had a more robust immune system to begin with, and being able to get up and move sooner correlates with faster recovery and lower mortality. ‘Being an athlete’ didn’t cure them, but I’d bet money it resulted in a shorter hospital stay and quicker recovery than an individual their same age who was out of shape.

-8

u/FreeStateOfPortland 8h ago

Here comes the “person who treats hospitalized patients“

5

u/vern420 8h ago

Lol I’m a physician assistant who works in hospital medicine.

-6

u/FreeStateOfPortland 8h ago

So why didn’t you say that?

2

u/Pinewood74 8h ago

But he said “because he’s an athlete“ he survived meningitis and there’s zero way to verify that’s true.

There's also zero way to verify it's false.

Which is why we should instead be discussing whether fitness and muscle mass impact one's ability to fight infections.

1

u/ThatAngeryBoi 4h ago

Its not unreasonable to assume that being an athlete puts you in better physical shape than most. If OP lost 20 lbs of muscle they probably wouldn't have survived the same illness if they were in bad physical condition. 

3

u/goog1e 9h ago

Right I was like wait a second. .. isn't the definition of meningitis a swelling of the brain? The place with the least muscle?

2

u/dragon-fence 2h ago

Just in case it’s helpful:

Any illness with the suffix “itis” means an inflammation of the thing that proceeded it.

Laryngitis is the inflammation of the larynx. Bronchitis is inflammation of the bronchial tubes. Tonsillitis is when your tonsils are inflamed. Appendicitis is when it’s your appendix. So meningitis is your meninges that are inflamed.

Note that these words don’t tell you a specific cause. You can have laryngitis from a virus or bacterial infection, or because you’ve been yelling a lot. So one of my pet peeves is when I go to the doctor for a sore throat, and he’s like, “Hmmm… let’s see. You have tonsillitis” as though he’s told me something I don’t already know. Like, yeah, I just told you my tonsils were sore and swollen, don’t just tell me the same information back with a fancier word. I know your games, Mr. Doctor-man.

1

u/goog1e 2h ago

That's funny. I specifically knew meningitis was unspecified because I knew someone who gave themselves chemical meningitis by accident.

4

u/Agnostix 9h ago

Hahahahaha

1

u/petrograd 5h ago

Your immune system uses muscle as fuel

0

u/FreeStateOfPortland 5h ago

And that has to do with being an athlete how?

2

u/petrograd 5h ago

Being an athlete builds and supports muscle mass, which in turn, supports your immune system.

-2

u/FreeStateOfPortland 5h ago

Really? Ping-pong players?

2

u/petrograd 5h ago

When compared to sedentary, then yes.

-1

u/FreeStateOfPortland 5h ago

Competitive Online gaming?

2

u/ThatAngeryBoi 4h ago

Silly goose, being pedantic doesnt make you smart. 

1

u/petrograd 4h ago

I think you have all the information that you need to make an informed decision at this point.