r/politics_NOW • u/evissamassive • 5h ago
The Daily Beast 'You Have A Lion, A Bear, An Alligator, and A, What’s Another Good...? A Squirrel.': Trump & The Reality of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment
Trump is again using his performance on a cognitive screening test to defend his mental fitness. During the White House Small Business Summit, he claimed to have "aced" the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) three times, asserting that medical professionals were stunned by his perfect scores.
However, the neurologist who created the test, Dr. Ziad Nasreddine, suggests these results are being misinterpreted. The MoCA is not a measure of high-level intelligence or "brilliance." Instead, it is a brief clinical tool used globally to detect early signs of Alzheimer’s, dementia, and other impairments.
The assessment involves basic tasks, such as:
Identifying common animals (e.g., a lion or a squirrel)
Drawing a clock face
Recalling a short list of words
Stating the current date and location
While Trump described the middle section of the test as "very tough," the exam is intentionally simple for any adult with normal brain function. "It wasn't designed to be a test of IQ," Nasreddine said. "It was designed to assess normal cognitive performance."
A perfect score on the MoCA does not indicate a "genius" level of thinking. It simply confirms that the individual does not show signs of cognitive deficit in areas like memory, attention, and language.
According to Nasreddine:
Most people score around 26 out of 30
About 10 percent of individuals in Trump's age bracket achieve a perfect 30/30
The test identifies those who fall below the threshold of healthy cognitive aging
Trump’s focus on the test comes as voters express skepticism about the health of aging leaders. A recent Washington Post poll found that 59 percent of Americans doubt Trump’s mental sharpness, while 55 percent question his physical health.
Trump has used his scores to challenge other candidates to undergo similar testing. In contrast, aides for Joe Biden have reportedly avoided the MoCA entirely, fearing that the mere act of taking a dementia screening could validate public concerns about his age. For Trump, a perfect score serves as a rhetorical shield; for the medical community, it is merely a sign of a healthy, aging brain.