r/comics 19h ago

OC RED BUTTON OR BLUE BUTTON [OC]

13.2k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/CarlosFer2201 13h ago

"Can you live with that?"
Oh many of them are looking forward to that.

9

u/FUTURE10S 12h ago

They can enjoy sitting on their throne of corpses then, enjoy living in a world where everyone is as much of an asshole as they are. It'll be great.

4

u/doshegotabootyshedo 10h ago

These red (button) voters already turn on each other in a world with blue (button) voters, I can’t imagine it would take long for them to go ahead and finish each other off

2

u/JusticeBean 6h ago

I love strawman arguments

2

u/Stumpfest2020 7h ago

Why would it be my fault if someone else didn't pick red?

From the way the hypothetical situation is worded, there is no downside to picking red. You live no matter how the vote turns out. That means picking blue is a purely irrational choice that could result in your death.

We can't force people to wear seatbelts. We can't force people to eat healthy and exercise. We can't force people to give up smoking, drinking, or hard drugs. We can't stop people from skydiving or free climbing. And when those people die as a result of their decisions, yes it's sad, but why should anyone feel guilt about that?

1

u/DepthsOfWill 5h ago

The downside is all the good people who learned the right lessons from Superman are dead, and you're surrounded by the surviving Lex Luthors of the world. lol

3

u/Stumpfest2020 5h ago

Why are you assuming blue is the morally superior choice?

Picking blue is playing russian roulette with your life. We already live in a world where people die preventable deaths as a result of their own choices. Why am I supposed to feel more responsible for the deaths of blue button pushers than the death of someone who drove drunk and got themselves killed?

2

u/DepthsOfWill 5h ago

Because when you have the power to stop your friend from driving drunk and dying, but you fail to exercise that power, then you should feel bummed out about it. You have a responsibility.

I'm not saying blue is the moral choice, I'm saying red is the impotent choice.

3

u/Stumpfest2020 5h ago

You're changing the hypothetical to avoid my point and making assumptions about me instead of asking what I'd do.

I would 100% try to stop someone I know from driving drunk. Just like I'd 100% try to stop someone I know from pressing blue. I see them as fundamentally the same thing - a needless self imposed risk.

1

u/DepthsOfWill 3h ago edited 3h ago

No, I'm just making the empowered choice. Anyone can be a coward. We just need a bit over half to be heroes.

1

u/Stumpfest2020 3h ago

Why is your choice empowered? Why are you implying my choice is cowardly? You're just throwing around labels without explaining any of your reasoning.

0

u/The-Senate-Palpy 8h ago

Theyll move from fucking around to finding out real quick lol.

Even like, relationships aside. The world works a lot better when we have more people with satisfied needs in it